The Effects of Adverse Life Events on Brain Development in the ABCD Study: A Propensity-weighted Analysis

Amanda Elton,Ben Lewis,Sara Jo Nixon
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.25.24314355
2024-09-26
Abstract:Longitudinal studies of the effects of adversity on human brain development are complicated by the association of stressful events with confounding variables. To counter this bias, we apply a propensity-weighted analysis of the first two years of The Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study data, employing a machine learning analysis weighted by individuals' propensity to experience adversity. Data included 338 resting-state functional connections from 7190 youth (46% female), divided into a training group (80%) and an independent testing group (20%). Propensity scores were computed using 390 variables to balance across two-year adverse life event exposures. Using elastic net regularization with and without inverse propensity weighting, we developed linear models in which changes in functional connectivity of brain connections during the two-year period served as predictors of the number of adverse events experienced during that same period. Haufe's method was applied to forward-transform the backward prediction models. We also tested whether brain changes associated with adverse events correlated with concomitant changes in internalizing or externalizing behaviors or to academic achievement. In the propensity-weighted analysis, brain development significantly predicted the number of adverse events experienced during that period in both the training group (ρ=0.14, p<0.001) and the independent testing group (ρ=0.10, p<0.001). The predictor indicated a general pattern of decreased functional connectivity between large-scale networks and subcortical brain regions, particularly for cingulo-opercular and sensorimotor networks. These network-to-subcortical functional connectivity decreases inversely associated with the development of internalizing symptoms, suggesting adverse events promoted adaptive brain changes that may buffer against stress-related psychopathology. However, these same functional connections were also associated with poorer grades at the two-year follow-up. Although cortical-subcortical brain developmental responses to adversity potentially shield against stress-induced mood and anxiety disorders, they may be detrimental to other domains such as academic success.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to explore the impact of adverse life events on adolescent brain development. Specifically, using data from The Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) Study, researchers examined the relationship between the number of adverse life events experienced within a two - year period and changes in brain functional connectivity through propensity - weighted analysis methods. The main objectives of the study are: 1. **Evaluating the impact of adverse life events on the development of brain functional connectivity**: By analyzing the resting - state functional connectivity data of 7,190 adolescents (46% female), researchers attempted to determine whether and how adverse life events affect the changes in functional connectivity between brain networks. 2. **Balancing potential confounding variables**: Using the propensity score weighting method to balance various confounding factors that may affect the relationship between adverse life events and brain development, such as socioeconomic status, ethnic identity, family structure, and community environment. 3. **Exploring the relationship between brain changes and behavioral changes**: Further testing whether the changes in functional brain connectivity related to adverse life events are associated with changes in internalizing or externalizing behaviors and academic performance. ### Main findings - **The development of brain functional connectivity significantly predicts the number of adverse life events**: In the training group (\(\rho = 0.14, p < 0.001\)) and the independent test group (\(\rho = 0.10, p < 0.001\)), changes in brain functional connectivity significantly predict the number of adverse life events experienced by individuals during these two years. - **Reduction in specific brain network connections**: Mainly manifested as a reduction in functional connectivity between large - scale brain networks and subcortical brain regions, especially the cingulate - opercular network and the sensorimotor network. - **The reduction in functional connectivity is negatively correlated with the development of internalizing symptoms**: This indicates that adverse life events may promote adaptive brain changes, which help buffer stress - related psychopathology. - **The impact of adverse life events on academic performance**: Although these brain changes may help protect individuals from stress - induced anxiety and depression, they are also associated with a decline in academic performance two years later. ### Method overview - **Data source**: Using data from the first two years of the ABCD study, including 338 resting - state functional connectivities. - **Sample division**: The data were divided into a training group (80%) and an independent test group (20%). - **Propensity score calculation**: Using 390 variables to calculate propensity scores to balance different levels of exposure to adverse life events. - **Elastic - net regression**: Using the elastic - net regularization method to predict the number of adverse life events, analyzed under unweighted and inverse - probability - weighted conditions respectively. - **Brain - behavior correlation analysis**: Testing whether the changes in functional brain connectivity related to adverse life events are associated with changes in internalizing or externalizing behaviors and academic performance. Through these methods, researchers hope to more clearly understand the specific impact of adverse life events on adolescent brain development and explore the potential implications of these brain changes for behavior and academic performance.