Turning the tables: Loss of adaptive immunity reverses sex differences in tuberculosis

David Hertz,Lars Eggers,Linda von Borstel,Torsten Goldmann,Hannelore Lotter,Bianca E Schneider

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.24.614709

2024-09-26

Abstract:Sex-based differences in innate immunity may play a crucial role in susceptibility to and progression of tuberculosis (TB), a disease that disproportionately affects men. This study aimed to examine whether early host-pathogen interactions contribute to the heightened vulnerability of males to Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) infection. Using recombination activating gene knockout (RAG KO) mice, which lack adaptive immunity, we were able to isolate and analyze innate immune responses to Mtb without the influence of T and B cells. Surprisingly, and in stark contrast to wild-type mice that reflect the male bias as observed in humans, female RAG KO mice were more susceptible to Mtb than their male counterparts. Increased lung CFU in females was accompanied by a significant rise in inflammation, indicated by elevated levels of inflammatory cytokines and chemokines, as well as a massive influx of neutrophils into the lungs. In contrast, male mice exhibited higher levels of IFN-gamma and CCL5, along with a greater presence of NK cells in their lungs, suggesting that, in the absence of adaptive immunity, males benefit from a more robust NK cell response, potentially offering greater protection by better controlling inflammation and slowing disease progression.

Immunology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore whether gender differences affect disease susceptibility and progression in the early stage of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) infection, especially in the absence of adaptive immune responses. Specifically, the researchers used recombination - activating gene knockout (RAG KO) mice, which lack mature B and T lymphocytes, thereby excluding the influence of the adaptive immune system and focusing on analyzing gender differences in the innate immune response.

### Main research questions:
1. **The impact of gender differences on Mtb infection**: Researchers want to understand the differences in the innate immune response between male and female mice in the early stage of Mtb infection, and how these differences affect disease susceptibility and progression.
2. **Gender differences in the absence of adaptive immunity**: By using RAG KO mice, researchers hope to explore whether gender differences still exist in the absence of the adaptive immune system, and the specific manifestations of such differences.

### Research background:
- **Gender differences in tuberculosis (TB)**: Tuberculosis is more common in men, which is usually attributed to behavioral factors (such as smoking and drinking). However, recent studies have shown that biological factors may also play an important role in gender differences.
- **Adaptive immunity and innate immunity**: Previous studies have mainly focused on the role of the adaptive immune system, but the role of the innate immune system in early - stage infection is equally important. Therefore, researchers hope to more clearly understand gender differences in the innate immune system by excluding the influence of adaptive immunity.

### Research methods:
- **Experimental animals**: Use RAG KO mice, which lack mature B and T lymphocytes, thereby excluding the influence of adaptive immunity.
- **Infection model**: Monitor the disease progression and survival of mice by aerosol - infecting the Mtb HN878 strain.
- **Index detection**: Determine the bacterial load in the lungs, mediastinal lymph nodes, spleen, and liver, and evaluate body weight changes, clinical scores, and survival rates. At the same time, evaluate the inflammatory response and immune cell infiltration through multi - factor cytokine detection and histological analysis.

### Main findings:
- **Gender differences**: In RAG KO mice, female mice showed a higher bacterial load, more severe weight loss, and a higher mortality rate than male mice.
- **Inflammatory response**: The inflammatory response in female mice was more intense, manifested as high - level inflammatory cytokines and chemokines, and a large number of neutrophil infiltrations.
- **The role of NK cells**: The number of NK cells and IFN - γ levels were higher in male mice, which may protect the host from immunopathological damage by regulating the inflammatory response.

### Conclusions:
- **Gender differences in the absence of adaptive immunity**: In the absence of the adaptive immune system, female mice are more susceptible to Mtb infection, manifested as a more severe inflammatory response and a higher bacterial load.
- **The protective role of NK cells**: The higher number of NK cells and IFN - γ levels in male mice may help control the inflammatory response and slow down disease progression.

In general, this study reveals the impact of gender differences on disease susceptibility and progression in the early stage of Mtb infection, and emphasizes the crucial role of the innate immune system in this process.