The mean and variance of infection load reveal unseen host evolution

Jason Cosens Walsman,Sabrina H Streipert,Cheryl J Briggs,Mark Q Wilber

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.24.614578

2024-09-25

Abstract:Some hosts are more heavily infected than others, but this fact has been relatively neglected in the microparasite literature compared to the macroparasite literature. We develop a model that allows host population mean and variance of microparasite load to fluctuate dynamically over time, dependent on underlying processes. Our model uses empirically reasonable, non-linear functional forms, e.g., for the probability of infected hosts surviving as a function of load. Despite non-linearities, we derive an approximation that assumes a lognormal distribution of load, improving computational and analytical tractability. We show negative feedbacks between load mean and variance at equilibrium. These feedbacks determine how a change in the host-microparasite system shifts mean and variance in load, directly as well as indirectly. We parameterize this model with empirically supported parameter values for a focal frog-fungal pathogen system. We illustrate system changes through evolution of host defenses against microparasites that may drive evolutionary recovery from disease-induced declines. We find that different forms of host defenses have different implications for load, e.g., constitutive resistance has little impact on the standard deviation while inducible resistance decreases it, with different outcomes for host fitness, pathogen fitness, and our ability to infer underlying dynamics from population-level data.

Ecology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem this paper attempts to address is exploring how the mean and variance of microbial parasite infection load (i.e., infection intensity) in host populations dynamically change over time and uncovering the biological mechanisms behind these changes. Specifically, the authors focus on the following aspects:

1. **Negative feedback relationship between the mean and variance of infection load**: The study finds that there is a negative feedback relationship between the mean and variance of infection load at equilibrium, which determines how changes in the host-microbial parasite system affect the mean and variance of the load.

2. **Impact of different forms of host defenses on infection load**: Through parameterized models, the authors explore the different impacts of various types of host defenses (such as innate resistance and induced resistance) on the mean and variance of infection load, and how these impacts further affect the fitness of hosts and pathogens.

3. **Dynamics of infection load during evolutionary recovery**: Using the mountain yellow-legged frog (*Rana muscosa*) as an example, the authors study how host evolution drives changes in infection load, particularly during the recovery process following population declines caused by disease.

4. **Role of variance in epidemiological dynamics**: The authors emphasize that the variance of infection load not only reflects biological mechanisms within the host but also significantly affects epidemiological dynamics, such as through superspreading phenomena.

5. **Improvement of modeling methods**: To better understand and analyze these dynamic changes, the authors developed a reduced Integral Projection Model (reduced IPM), which assumes that the log distribution of infection load is normally distributed, thereby simplifying the model's dimensions and improving computational efficiency and analytical operability.

In summary, through theoretical modeling and empirical data, this paper reveals the importance of the mean and variance of infection load in host-microbial parasite systems and their impact on evolutionary and epidemiological dynamics.