Working memory predicts long-term recognition of auditory sequences: Dissociation between confirmed predictions and prediction errors

L. Bonetti,E. Risgaard Olsen,F. Carlomagno,E. Serra,S.A. Szabó,M. Klarlund,M.H. Andersen,L. Frausing,P. Vuust,E. Brattico,M.L. Kringelbach,G. Fernández-Rubio
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.20.614110
2024-09-20
Abstract:Memory is a crucial cognitive process involving several subsystems: sensory memory (SM), short-term memory (STM), working memory (WM), and long-term memory (LTM). While each has been extensively studied, the interaction between WM and LTM, particularly in relation to predicting temporal sequences, remains largely unexplored. This study investigates the relationship between WM and LTM, and how these relate to aging and musical training. Using three datasets with a total of 244 healthy volunteers across various age groups, we examined the impact of WM on LTM recognition of novel and previously memorized musical sequences. Our results show that WM abilities are significantly related to recognition of novel sequences, with a more pronounced effect in older compared to younger adults. In contrast, WM did not similarly impact the recognition of memorized sequences, which implies that different cognitive processes are involved in handling prediction errors compared to confirmatory predictions, and that WM contributes to these processes differently. Additionally, our findings confirm that musical training enhances memory performance. Future research should extend our investigation to populations with cognitive impairments and explore the underlying neural substrates.
Neuroscience
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the relationship between working memory (WM) and long - term memory (LTM), especially how this relationship affects the memory recognition of auditory sequences, and the differences in these relationships among different age groups and with different music - training backgrounds. Specifically, through experiments on three data sets, the researchers examined how working - memory ability affects the long - term - memory recognition of new and already - memorized sequences, and whether this effect varies with age and music training. ### Research Background - **Memory Systems**: Memory is divided into multiple subsystems, including sensory memory (SM), short - term memory (STM), working memory (WM), and long - term memory (LTM). Each subsystem has its specific functions, but there are also interactions among them. - **Predictive Coding Theory**: The Predictive Coding Theory (PCT) holds that the brain processes information by generating predictions and comparing them with actual inputs. When the prediction does not match the actual input, a prediction error is generated, which is crucial for cognitive processes. - **Music Sequences**: Music sequences, due to their temporal continuity and the dynamic generation of meaning, become ideal materials for studying memory recognition. ### Research Purposes - **Explore the Relationship between WM and LTM**: The researchers hope to verify through experiments how working memory (WM) affects sequence recognition in long - term memory (LTM), especially the different performances when dealing with new and already - memorized sequences. - **The Influence of Age and Music Training**: The study also explores how age and music training affect this relationship, especially the performance of the elderly and those with music training in memory - recognition tasks. ### Main Findings - **The Influence of WM on New - Sequence Recognition**: The study found that working - memory ability significantly affects the long - term - memory recognition of new sequences, especially in the data sets of 2022 and 2024. This indicates that working memory plays an important role in dealing with prediction errors (i.e., situations where new sequences do not match expectations). - **The Influence of Age**: As age increases, working - memory ability declines, which leads to poorer performance of the elderly in recognizing new sequences. - **The Influence of Music Training**: Music training can enhance memory performance, both in recognizing new sequences and already - memorized sequences. ### Conclusions - **The Interaction between WM and LTM**: The interaction between working memory and long - term memory is particularly evident when dealing with new sequences, which supports the view of the Predictive Coding Theory that prediction errors play an important role in cognitive processes. - **Future Research Directions**: Future research should further explore whether these findings are applicable to people with cognitive impairments and further investigate the relevant neural mechanisms. Through these studies, we can better understand the complexity of the memory system and its performance under different conditions, thus providing valuable insights for cognitive science and clinical applications.