From Genes to Patterns: A Framework for Modeling the Emergence of Embryonic Development from Transcriptional Regulation

Jimena Garcia-Guillen,Ezzat El-Sherif

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.19.613926

2024-10-10

Abstract:Understanding embryonic patterning, the process by which groups of cells are partitioned into distinct identities defined by gene expression, is a central challenge in developmental biology. This complex phenomenon is driven by precise spatial and temporal regulation of gene expression across many cells, resulting in the emergence of highly organized tissue structures. While similar emergent behavior is well understood in other fields, such as statistical mechanics, the regulation of gene expression in development remains less clear, particularly regarding how molecular-level gene interactions lead to the large-scale patterns observed in embryos. In this study, we present a modeling framework that bridges the gap between molecular gene regulation and tissue-level embryonic patterning. Beginning with basic chemical reaction models of transcription at the single-gene level, we progress to model gene regulatory networks (GRNs) that mediate specific cellular functions. We then introduce phenomenological models of pattern formation, including the French Flag and Temporal Patterning/Speed Regulation models, and integrate them with molecular/GRN realizations. To facilitate understanding and application of our models, we accompany our mathematical framework with computer simulations, providing intuitive and simple code for each model. A key feature of our framework is the explicit articulation of underlying assumptions at each level of the model, from transcriptional regulation to tissue patterning. By making these assumptions clear, we provide a foundation for future experimental and theoretical work to critically examine and challenge them, thereby improving the accuracy and relevance of gene regulatory models in developmental biology. As a case study, we explore how different strategies for integrating enhancer activity affect the robustness and evolvability of gene expression patterns in embryonic development. Our simulations suggest that a two-step regulation strategy, enhancer activation followed by competitive integration at the promoter, ensures more standardized integration of new enhancers into developmental GRNs, highlighting the adaptability of eukaryotic transcription. These findings provide new insights into the transcriptional mechanisms underlying embryonic patterning, offering a framework for future experimental and theoretical investigations.

Developmental Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the problem of understanding the process of embryonic patterning in developmental biology. Specifically, embryonic patterning refers to how groups of cells are segmented into different identities defined by gene expression, which precisely regulates gene expression in space and time, ultimately forming highly organized tissue structures. Although similar emergent behaviors have been well understood in other fields such as statistical mechanics, the mechanisms of gene expression regulation during development remain unclear, particularly how gene interactions at the molecular level lead to the large-scale patterns observed in embryos.

To fill this knowledge gap, the authors propose a modeling framework aimed at connecting gene regulation at the molecular level with embryonic patterning at the tissue level. The framework starts with basic chemical reaction models at the single-gene level and gradually develops into models of gene regulatory networks (GRNs) that mediate specific cellular functions. Then, representational models of pattern formation, including the French flag model and temporal pattern/velocity regulation models, are introduced and combined with molecular/GRN implementations. Additionally, to facilitate understanding and application of these models, the authors provide computer simulations for each model, accompanied by intuitive and simple code. By explicitly stating the fundamental assumptions at each level of the models, the authors provide a basis for critical testing and challenges in future experimental and theoretical work, thereby improving the accuracy and relevance of gene regulation models in developmental biology.

As a case study, the authors explore the impact of different strategies for integrating enhancer activity on the robustness and evolvability of gene expression patterns during embryonic development. Simulation results indicate that a two-step regulatory strategy (first activating the enhancer, then competitively integrating at the promoter) ensures that new enhancers are integrated into developmental GRNs in a more standardized manner, highlighting the adaptability of eukaryotic transcription. These findings provide new insights into the transcriptional mechanisms of embryonic patterning and offer a framework for future experimental and theoretical research.