Qualitative EEG abnormalities signal a shift towards inhibition-dominated brain networks. Results from the EU-AIMS LEAP studies
Erika L Juarez-Martinez,Arthur-Ervin Avramiea,Pilar Garcés,Joerg F Hipp,Simon-Shlomo Poil,Marina Diachenko,Huib Mansvelder,Emily JH Jones,Luke Mason,Declan Murphy,Eva Loth,Bethany Oakley,Tony Charman,Tobias Banaschewski,Bob Oranje,Jan Buitelaar,Hilgo Bruining,Klaus Linkenkaer-Hansen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.19.613847
2024-10-18
Abstract:Qualitative EEG abnormalities are common in Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and hypothesized to reflect disrupted excitation/inhibition balance. To test this, we recently introduced a functional measure of network-level E/I ratio (fE/I). Here, we applied fE/I and other quantitative EEG measures to alpha oscillations from source-reconstructed data in the EU-AIMS compilation of 267 EEG recordings from children-adolescents and adults with ASD and 209 controls. We analyzed these quantitative measures alongside evaluating for qualitative EEG abnormalities ranging from slowing of activity to epileptiform patterns aiming to replicate the findings from the SPACE-BAMBI study (Bruining et al., 2020). EEG abnormalities were only identified in a few adults and could not be statistically assessed. ASD children-adolescents with EEG abnormalities exhibited lower relative alpha power and lower fE/I compared to children-adolescents without abnormalities; however, the EEG-abnormality scoring did not stratify the behavioral heterogeneity of ASD using clinical measures. Surprisingly, several controls presented with qualitative EEG abnormalities and showed a strikingly similar anatomical distribution of lower fE/I to the one observed in the ASD group, suggesting a shift towards inhibition-dominated network dynamics, in regions associated with altered sensory processing. The robustness of this association between EEG abnormalities and reduced fE/I was further supported by re-analysis of the SPACE-BAMBI study in source space. Stratification by the presence of EEG abnormalities and their associated effects on network activity may help understand neurodevelopmental physiological heterogeneity and the difficulties in implementing E/I targeting treatments in unselected cohorts.
Neuroscience
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects:
1. **Explore the relationship between electroencephalogram (EEG) abnormalities in autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and the network - level excitation/inhibition (E/I) ratio**:
- The researchers hypothesized that the qualitative abnormalities in EEG might reflect the disruption of the excitation - inhibition balance in the brain network. They used a new functional E/I ratio (fE/I) to quantify this balance and hoped to verify this hypothesis by analyzing EEG data.
2. **Evaluate the manifestations of EEG abnormalities in children, adolescents, and adult ASD patients and their differences from the control group**:
- By analyzing the large - scale EEG data collected in the EU - AIMS project, the researchers hoped to understand the frequency of EEG abnormalities in ASD patients of different age groups and explore whether these abnormalities were related to specific neurophysiological characteristics.
3. **Explore the impact of EEG abnormalities on the behavioral heterogeneity of ASD**:
- The researchers also attempted to understand whether EEG abnormalities could explain the differences in clinical manifestations of ASD patients, especially whether these abnormalities affected the behavioral characteristics and adaptive behavior abilities of ASD.
4. **Verify the findings of previous studies**:
- This study aimed to replicate the findings in the SPACE - BAMBI study, that is, EEG abnormalities were related to the decreased fE/I ratio, which indicated a shift in brain network dynamics towards inhibition - dominated.
5. **Explore the manifestations of EEG abnormalities in the normal population**:
- The researchers also observed that even in the control group without an ASD diagnosis, there were EEG abnormalities, and these abnormalities showed an anatomical distribution pattern similar to that of the ASD group, which suggested that EEG abnormalities might not be a unique marker of ASD only.
In summary, the main objective of this paper is to explore the relationship between EEG abnormalities and the network - level E/I ratio in ASD patients, as well as the impact of these abnormalities on the behavioral heterogeneity of ASD, while verifying the findings of previous studies and exploring the manifestations of EEG abnormalities in the normal population through the analysis of large - scale EEG data.