A neural network model for the evolution of reconstructive social learning

Jacob Chisausky,Inès Marguerite Daras,Franz J. Weissing,Magdalena Kozielska
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.18.613615
2024-09-21
Abstract:Learning from others is an important adaptation. However, the evolution of social learning and its role in the spread of socially transmitted information are not well understood. Few models of social learning account for the fact that socially transmitted information must be reconstructed by the learner, based on the learner’s previous knowledge and cognition. To represent the reconstructive nature of social learning, we present a modelling framework that incorporates the evolution of a neural network and a simple yet biologically realistic learning mechanism. The framework encompasses various forms of individual and social learning and allows the investigation of their interplay. Individual-based simulations reveal that an effective neural network structure rapidly evolves, leading to adaptive inborn behaviour in static environments, pure individual learning in highly variable environments, and a combination of individual and social learning in environments of intermediate stability. However, the evolutionary outcome depends strongly on the type of social learning (social guidance versus social instruction) and the order of individual and social learning. Moreover, the evolutionary dynamics of social learning can be surprisingly complex, with replicate simulations converging to alternative outcomes. We discuss the relevance of our modelling framework for cultural evolution and suggest future avenues of research.
Evolutionary Biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the evolution of social learning and its role in socially transmitted information. Specifically, the author focuses on how to simulate and understand through neural network models how individuals in the social learning process reconstruct the received social information based on their prior knowledge and cognitive abilities. The paper proposes a modeling framework that combines the evolution of neural networks and a simple yet biologically realistic learning mechanism, covering various forms of individual and social learning and allowing the study of their interactions. ### Main problems: 1. **Evolution of social learning**: How can effective social learning strategies be formed through the evolutionary process? 2. **Combination of social and individual learning**: How do individual and social learning interact under different environmental conditions? 3. **Different types of social learning**: How do social guidance and social instruction differently affect the evolutionary results? 4. **Impact of environmental change**: How does the stability and rate of change of the environment affect the evolution of social and individual learning? ### Solutions: - **Modeling framework**: Use a neural network model to simulate how individuals predict food quality based on external cues and adjust these predictions through learning. - **Learning mechanism**: Introduce the "Delta rule" as a learning algorithm, enabling the neural network to adjust according to prediction errors. - **Combination of individual and social learning**: Consider different combinations of self - directed individual learning, socially - guided learning, and socially - instructed learning. - **Environmental setting**: By changing the frequency and magnitude of environmental change, study the evolution of learning strategies under different environmental conditions. ### Key findings: - **Environmental stability**: In a static environment, adaptive innate behaviors evolve rapidly; in a highly variable environment, pure individual learning evolves; in a moderately stable environment, combined strategies of individual and social learning evolve. - **Types of social learning**: Social guidance and social instruction have a significant impact on evolutionary results, and replication simulations may converge to different results. - **Complex dynamics**: The evolutionary dynamics of social learning can be very complex, with multiple possible evolutionary paths. Through these studies, the paper aims to provide a more realistic representation method for theoretical models of cultural evolution and offer new perspectives for further research.