Extracellular vesicle bioactivity and potential clinical utility is determined by mesenchymal stromal cell clonal subtype

Savvas Ioannou,Alasdair G. Kay,Andrew P. Stone,Emma Rand,Samuel Elberfeld,William Bolton,Tony Larson,Rachel E. Crossland,Oksana Kehoe,David A. Mentlak,Xiao-Nong Wang,Chris MacDonald,Paul G. Genever
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.05.609844
2024-09-05
Abstract:Mesenchymal stromal cells (MSCs) are a promising source of therapeutic extracellular vesicles (EVs), however it is not clear how heterogeneity within a non-clonal MSC population will affect the collective EV pool. Here we used immortalised clonal MSC lines, termed Y201 and Y202, to examine how MSC phenotype influences EV character and function. Although morphologically similar, Y201 EVs were more abundant in EV biomarkers versus Y202 EVs, with an enhanced miRNA and proteomic content, predicted to contribute to an elaborate EV corona particularly abundant in RGD-containing proteins fibronectin and MFG-E8. We demonstrated that Y201 EVs, but not Y202 EVs, significantly increased the proliferation of articular chondrocytes and that the proliferative effect was mediated at least in part via an RGD (integrin)-FAK-ERK1/2 axis. Both Y201 and Y202 EV subsets significantly reduced proliferative index scores of activated T cells. However, only Y201 EVs, not Y202 EVs, suppressed disease activity compared to controls in different models of inflammatory peritonitis and arthritis. EVs released by closely related MSC subtypes within the same heterogeneous population differ significantly in terms of cargo abundance, bioactivity, and pre-clinical efficacy. Analysis of defined EV subsets will aid mechanistic understanding and prioritisation for EV therapeutics.
Cell Biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to explore the influence of mesenchymal stromal cell (MSCs) clonal subtypes on the bioactivity of extracellular vesicles (EVs) and their potential clinical applications. Specifically, the researchers used two immortalized clonal MSC lines (Y201 and Y202) isolated from the same donor to investigate how different MSC phenotypes affect the characteristics and functions of the EVs they secrete. ### Main research questions: 1. **The influence of MSC heterogeneity on the EV pool**: How does the heterogeneity within non - clonal MSC populations affect the composition and function of the overall EV pool? 2. **Differences in EV bioactivity**: Are there significant differences in the bioactivity of EVs from different MSC subtypes? 3. **Differences in pre - clinical efficacy**: Are there significant differences in the efficacy of EVs from different MSC subtypes in pre - clinical models? ### Research background: - **The therapeutic potential of MSCs**: MSCs show potential in the treatment of various diseases due to their tri - lineage differentiation ability and immunosuppressive properties. - **EVs as a therapeutic tool**: As extracellular vesicles, EVs can carry biomolecules such as proteins, mRNA, and miRNA, and exert biological effects through interaction with target cells, becoming a potential cell - free therapy. - **The problem of MSC heterogeneity**: Non - clonal, heterogeneous MSC cultures have unstable effects in clinical applications, which hinders their further development. ### Research methods: - **Cell culture**: Two MSC lines, Y201 and Y202, were used for culturing. - **EV isolation**: EVs were isolated from the cell culture supernatant by differential ultra - centrifugation. - **Bioactivity detection**: The bioactivity of EVs was evaluated by multiple experimental techniques such as nanoparticle tracking analysis, transmission electron microscopy, Western Blot, proteomics, and lipidomics analysis. - **Function verification**: The functional differences of different EVs were verified by methods such as cell proliferation experiments, flow cytometry, and confocal microscopy. ### Research findings: - **Y201 EVs vs. Y202 EVs**: Although they have similar morphologies, Y201 EVs are more abundant in EV markers, miRNA, and protein content, especially fibronectin containing the RGD motif and MFG - E8. - **Proliferation effect**: Y201 EVs significantly increased the proliferation of articular chondrocytes, while Y202 EVs did not have this effect. - **Immunomodulation**: Both EVs can significantly reduce the proliferation index of activated T cells, but only Y201 EVs showed the effect of suppressing disease activity in in - vivo models of inflammatory peritonitis and arthritis. ### Conclusions: - **Heterogeneity of EVs**: Even within the same MSC population, EVs released by different subtypes of MSCs have significant differences in cargo abundance, bioactivity, and pre - clinical efficacy. - **Mechanism understanding**: These findings contribute to a deeper understanding of the biological mechanisms of EVs and provide guidance for selecting appropriate EV sources for treatment. ### Keywords: - Mesenchymal stromal cells - Heterogeneity - Extracellular vesicles - Matrix proteins - Arthritis Through these studies, the paper provides important theoretical basis and technical support for the optimization of EVs in future clinical applications.