A Computational Framework to Optimize the Mechanical Behavior of Synthetic Vascular Grafts

David Jiang,Andrew J. Robinson,Abbey Nkansah,Jonathan Leung,Leopold Guo,Steve A. Maas,Jeffrey A. Weiss,Elizabeth M. Cosgriff-Hernandez,Lucas H. Timmins
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.05.608688
2024-09-07
Abstract:The failure of synthetic small-diameter vascular grafts has been attributed to a mismatch in the compliance between the graft and native artery, driving mechanisms that promote thrombosis and neointimal hyperplasia. Additionally, the buckling of grafts results in large deformations that can lead to device failure. Although design features can be added to lessen the buckling potential, the addition is detrimental to decreasing compliance (e.g., reinforcing coil). Herein, we developed a novel finite element framework to inform vascular graft design by evaluating compliance and resistance to buckling. A batch-processing scheme iterated across the multi-dimensional design parameter space, which included three parameters: coil thickness, modulus, and spacing. Three types of finite element models were created in for each unique coil-reinforced graft parameter combination to simulate pressurization, axial buckling, and bent buckling, and results were analyzed to quantify compliance, buckling load, and kink radius, respectively, from each model. Importantly, model validation demonstrated that model predictions agree qualitatively and quantitatively with experimental observations. Subsequently, data for each design parameter combination were integrated into an optimization function for which a minimum value was sought. The optimization values identified various candidate graft designs with promising mechanical properties. Our investigation successfully demonstrated the model-directed framework identified vascular graft designs with optimal mechanical properties, which can potentially improve clinical outcomes by addressing device failure. In addition, the presented computational framework promotes model-directed device design for a broad range of biomaterial and regenerative medicine strategies.
Bioengineering
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to solve the problem of failure in the clinical application of synthetic small - diameter vascular grafts (<6 mm). Specifically, the paper focuses on two main aspects: 1. **Compliance mismatch**: - The mismatch in compliance (radial stiffness) between synthetic vascular grafts and native arteries leads to thrombosis and neointimal hyperplasia (NH). This mismatch results in a complex biomechanical environment, manifested as disordered blood flow patterns and wall stress gradients at the anastomosis, thus affecting the long - term patency of the graft. 2. **Insufficient mechanical stability**: - The graft is prone to buckling under physiological loads, resulting in large deformations of the material and may cause structural failure. For example, axial buckling can cause the graft to bend or twist, increasing pressure loss and flow resistance and reducing distal perfusion; kinking may lead to significant restriction or even complete blockage of blood flow. ### Solutions To overcome the above problems, the paper developed a new finite - element (FE) modeling framework to optimize the design of synthetic vascular grafts by iterating through a multi - dimensional design - parameter space. The specific steps are as follows: 1. **Parameterized design space**: - Three key parameters were defined: coil thickness (/g2012), coil shear modulus (/g2020) and coil spacing (/g1868). Through the combination of these parameters, 100 unique coil - reinforced graft designs were generated. 2. **Finite - element model development**: - Three types of finite - element models were developed using the open - source software FEBio and FEBio Studio to simulate the behavior of the graft under pressurized, axially buckled and kinked conditions respectively. 3. **Model validation**: - The prediction results of the model were verified by experimental data to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the model. 4. **Optimization function**: - The simulation results of different combinations of design parameters were integrated into an optimization function to find the minimum value in order to identify the graft design with the best mechanical properties. ### Conclusions Through this model - guided framework, the paper successfully identified the vascular graft design with the optimal mechanical properties, which is expected to improve clinical outcomes and reduce the risk of device failure. In addition, this computational framework also promotes model - guided device design, which is applicable to a wide range of biomaterials and regenerative medicine strategies.