Spatial and temporal variation in farmland bird nesting ecology: Implications for effective Corn Bunting Emberiza calandra conservation

Nils Anthes,Julia Staggenborg,Markus Handschuh
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.02.610792
2024-09-03
Abstract:Farmland bird populations continue to decline despite intense conservation efforts, possibly also because of incomplete knowledge on the drivers of local productivity. We therefore investigated spatial and temporal variation in nest site selection, breeding phenology, and nest survival for 225 nests of the Corn Bunting, a species of conservation concern in Central and Western Europe, in cropland-dominated, mixed, and grassland-dominated landscapes in SW Central Europe. Nesting phenology spread from April to August, started earlier at lower altitudes and progressed from grassland habitats to arable crops and eco-scheme flower fields. Most nests were placed in cultivated land, with substantial variation between landscape types but also between years within sites, so that large fractions of breeding attempts are prone to fail through land use operations in particular years. When nests were individually protected from land use, 'apparent' and 'Mayfield' survival rates differed substantially between nest habitats, with lowest survival in 2nd year flower fields and highest survival in fallow grassland. Accounting for land use survival from patch-specific mowing, harvesting, and grazing dates, 'total Mayfield nest survival' estimates dropped by about half to 21 %, 13 %, and 20 % for (hay) meadows, alfalfa / clover-grass leys, and pastures, respectively, which held about 2/3 of nests in mixed landscapes. To enhance productivity beyond the thresholds required for local population persistence, we propose refined conservation schemes that improve survival within production farmland, best coupled with the development of prolific 'Corn Bunting Landscapes'.
Ecology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: Despite a great deal of conservation efforts, the population of farmland birds (especially the Corn Bunting Emberiza calandra) continues to decline. The researchers believe that this may be due to a lack of sufficient understanding of the key factors affecting local breeding success. Therefore, this study aims to explore the spatial and temporal variations in nest - site selection, breeding phenology, and nest survival rate of the Corn Bunting in different landscape types, and to evaluate how these factors are affected by land - use practices. Specifically, the research objectives include: 1. **Describe the changes in nest - site selection**: Analyze the differences in nest - site selection of the Corn Bunting in crop - dominated, mixed, and grass - dominated landscapes. 2. **Quantify breeding phenology and its changes**: Study the time distribution of the breeding season of the Corn Bunting from April to August, and analyze its changes in different regions, years, and habitats. 3. **Relate nest survival rate to environmental factors**: Evaluate the relationship between nest survival rate and nest habitat, season, and specific mowing, harvesting, and grazing schedules. Through these analyses, the researchers hope to evaluate whether it is necessary to adjust the conservation measures for the Corn Bunting according to different habitats or landscape characteristics in order to improve breeding success and ensure the continued existence of local populations. In addition, the study also proposes specific conservation plans to improve survival rates within productive farmland, and to develop "Corn Bunting landscapes" that are conducive to the reproduction of the Corn Bunting. ### Key formulas and statistical methods - **Mayfield daily nest survival rate (DSR)**: \[ DSR=\frac{\text{Number of nest days with successful survival}}{\text{Total number of nest days observed}} \] The Mayfield estimate takes into account the length of time each nest was surveyed, thus eliminating the obvious bias in nest survival rate. - **Total Mayfield nest survival rate**: \[ \text{Total Mayfield nest survival rate}=DSR^{25} \] Here, \(25\) is the sum of the incubation period (13 days) and the brooding period (12 days). - **Model evaluation**: Use the generalized linear mixed - effects model (GLMM), with the first egg - laying date (FED) as the response variable, the study area as the fixed predictor, and the study year as the random intercept. The model evaluation adopts a Gaussian distribution, excluding the data of second or replacement clutches that may produce extreme values. Through these methods, researchers can more accurately understand the spatio - temporal changes in the breeding ecology of the Corn Bunting and their impact on conservation strategies.