Abstract:Abstract Introduction: There is accumulating cross-sectional evidence of decreased within-network resting-state functional connectivity (RSFC) and increased between-network RSFC when comparing older to younger samples, but results from longitudinal studies with healthy aging samples are sparse and less consistent. Some of the variability might occur due to differences in network definition and the fact that most atlases were trained on young adult samples. Applying these atlases to older cohorts implies the generalizability of network definitions to older individuals. However, because age is linked to a less segregated network architecture, this assumption might not be valid. To account for this, the Atlas55+ (A55) was recently published. The A55 was trained on a sample of people over the age of 55, making the network solutions suitable for studies on the aging process. Here, we want to compare the A55 to the popular Yeo-Krienen atlas to investigate whether and to what extent differences in network definition influence longitudinal changes of RSFC. For this purpose, the following networks were investigated: the occipital network (ON, “visual network”), the pericentral network (PN, “somatomotor network”), the medial frontoparietal network (M-FPN, “default network”), the lateral frontoparietal network (L-FPN, “control network”), and the midcingulo-insular network (M-CIN, “salience network”). Methods: Analyses were performed using longitudinal data from cognitively healthy older adults (N = 228, mean age at baseline = 70.8 years) with five measurement points over seven years. To define the five networks, we used different variants of the two atlases. The spatial overlap of the networks was quantified using the dice similarity coefficient (DSC). RSFC trajectories within networks were estimated with latent growth curve models. Models of varying complexity were calculated, ranging from a linear model without interindividual variability in intercept and slope to a quadratic model with variability in intercept and slope. In addition, regressions were calculated in the models to explain the potential variance in the latent factors by baseline age, sex, and education. Finally, the regional homogeneity and the silhouette coefficient were computed, and the spin test and Wilcoxon-Mann-Whitney test were used to evaluate how well the atlases fit the data. Results: Median DSC across all comparisons was 0.67 (range: 0.20— 0.93). The spatial overlap was higher for primary processing networks in comparison to higher-order networks and for intra-atlas comparisons versus inter-atlas comparisons. Three networks (ON, PN, M-FPN) showed convergent shapes of trajectories (linear vs. quadratic), whereas the other two networks (L-FPN, M-CIN) showed differences in change over time depending on the atlas used. The 95% confidence intervals of the estimated time and age effects overlapped in most cases, so that differences were mainly evident regarding the p-value. The evaluation of the fit of the atlases to the data indicates that the Yeo-Krienen atlas is more suitable for our dataset, although it was not trained on a sample of older individuals. Conclusions: The atlas choice affects the estimated average RSFC in some networks, which highlights the importance of this methodological decision for future studies and calls for careful interpretation of already published results. Ultimately, there is no standard about how to operationalize networks. However, future studies may use and compare multiple atlases to assess the impact of network definition on outcomes. Ideally, the fit of the atlases to the data should be assessed, and heuristics such as "similar age range" or "frequently used" should be avoided when selecting atlases. Further, the validity of the networks should be evaluated by computing their associations with behavioral measures.

Dev-Atlas: A reference atlas of functional brain networks for typically developing adolescents

Generating Templates and Growth Charts for School-Aged Brain Development

Brainnetome atlas of preadolescent children based on anatomical connectivity profiles

A precision functional atlas of personalized network topography and probabilities

Integrated structural and functional atlases of Asian children from infancy to childhood

Human adolescent brain similarity development is different for paralimbic versus neocortical zones

Functional hypergraph uncovers novel covariant structures over neurodevelopment

Functional brain network organisation of children between 2 and 5years derived from reconstructed activity of cortical sources of high-density EEG recordings

Influence of Atlas-Choice on Age and Time Effects in Large-Scale Brain Networks in the Context of Healthy Aging

Assessing neurocognitive maturation in early adolescence based on baby and adult functional brain landscapes

Spatio-angular Consistent Construction of Neonatal Diffusion MRI Atlases.

Model-based network discovery of developmental and performance-related differences during risky decision-making

Prediction of Individual Brain Maturity Using fMRI

The Development of Functional Network Organization in Early Childhood and Early Adolescence: A Resting-State Fnirs Study.

Brain Maturation Study during Adolescence Using Graph Laplacian Learning Based Fourier Transform

Association between Brain Morphometry and Cognitive Function during Adolescence: Insights from a Comprehensive Large-Scale Analysis from 9 to 15 Years Old

Development of the default-mode network during childhood and adolescence: A longitudinal resting-state fMRI study

Developmental and aging resting functional magnetic resonance imaging brain state adaptations in adolescents and adults: A large N (>47K) study

Cross-sectional exploration of brain functional connectivity in the triadic development model of adolescents

Dataset factors associated with age-related changes in brain structure and function in neurodevelopmental conditions

Selective Development of Anticorrelated Networks in the Intrinsic Functional Organization of the Human Brain