Abstract:Background: People with chronic pain experience variability in their trajectories of pain severity. Previous studies have explored pain trajectories by clustering sparse data; however, to understand daily pain variability, there is a need to identify clusters of weekly trajectories using daily pain data. Between-week variability can be explored by quantifying the week-to-week movement between these clusters. We propose that future work can use clusters of pain severity in a forecasting model for short-term (eg, daily fluctuations) and longer-term (eg, weekly patterns) variability. Specifically, future work can use clusters of weekly trajectories to predict between-cluster movement and within-cluster variability in pain severity. Objective: This study aims to understand clusters of common weekly patterns as a first stage in developing a pain-forecasting model. Methods: Data from a population-based mobile health study were used to compile weekly pain trajectories (n=21,919) that were then clustered using a k-medoids algorithm. Sensitivity analyses tested the impact of assumptions related to the ordinal and longitudinal structure of the data. The characteristics of people within clusters were examined, and a transition analysis was conducted to understand the movement of people between consecutive weekly clusters. Results: Four clusters were identified representing trajectories of no or low pain (1714/21,919, 7.82%), mild pain (8246/21,919, 37.62%), moderate pain (8376/21,919, 38.21%), and severe pain (3583/21,919, 16.35%). Sensitivity analyses confirmed the 4-cluster solution, and the resulting clusters were similar to those in the main analysis, with at least 85% of the trajectories belonging to the same cluster as in the main analysis. Male participants spent longer (participant mean 7.9, 95% bootstrap CI 6%-9.9%) in the no or low pain cluster than female participants (participant mean 6.5, 95% bootstrap CI 5.7%-7.3%). Younger people (aged 17-24 y) spent longer (participant mean 28.3, 95% bootstrap CI 19.3%-38.5%) in the severe pain cluster than older people (aged 65-86 y; participant mean 9.8, 95% bootstrap CI 7.7%-12.3%). People with fibromyalgia (participant mean 31.5, 95% bootstrap CI 28.5%-34.4%) and neuropathic pain (participant mean 31.1, 95% bootstrap CI 27.3%-34.9%) spent longer in the severe pain cluster than those with other conditions, and people with rheumatoid arthritis spent longer (participant mean 7.8, 95% bootstrap CI 6.1%-9.6%) in the no or low pain cluster than those with other conditions. There were 12,267 pairs of consecutive weeks that contributed to the transition analysis. The empirical percentage remaining in the same cluster across consecutive weeks was 65.96% (8091/12,267). When movement between clusters occurred, the highest percentage of movement was to an adjacent cluster. Conclusions: The clusters of pain severity identified in this study provide a parsimonious description of the weekly experiences of people with chronic pain. These clusters could be used for future study of between-cluster movement and within-cluster variability to develop accurate and stakeholder-informed pain-forecasting tools.

Towards validation of clinical measures to discriminate between nociceptive, neuropathic and nociplastic pain: cluster analysis of a cohort with chronic musculoskeletal pain

Machine learning clinical decision support for interdisciplinary multimodal chronic musculoskeletal pain treatment

Features and methods to discriminate between mechanism-based categories of pain experienced in the musculoskeletal system: a Delphi expert consensus study

Disease Phenotypes in Refractory Musculoskeletal Pain Syndromes Identified by Unsupervised Machine Learning

A Biomarker-Centric Framework for the Prediction of Future Chronic Pain

Towards data-driven biopsychosocial classification of non-specific chronic low back pain: a pilot study

A novel cortical biomarker signature predicts individual pain sensitivity

Chronic Pain Diagnosis Using Machine Learning, Questionnaires, and QST: A Sensitivity Experiment

Identifying Weekly Trajectories of Pain Severity Using Daily Data From an mHealth Study: Cluster Analysis

Classification of painful or painless diabetic peripheral neuropathy and identification of the most powerful predictors using machine learning models in large cross-sectional cohorts

Definition and clinical validation of Pain Patient States from high-dimensional mobile data: application to a chronic pain cohort

Multimodal physiological sensing for the assessment of acute pain

Beyond pain: Using Unsupervised Machine Learning to Identify Phenotypic Clusters of Small Fiber Neuropathy

The Identification of Blood Biomarkers of Chronic Neuropathic Pain by Comparative Transcriptomics

Subgrouping of facilitatory or inhibitory conditioned pain modulation responses in patients with chronic knee pain. Explorative analysis from a multicentre trial

Clinical subtype analysis of neuropathic pain caused by peripheral nerve injury of upper extremity

The reliability of two prospective cortical biomarkers for pain: EEG peak alpha frequency and TMS corticomotor excitability

Validity of central pain processing biomarkers for predicting the occurrence of oncological chronic pain: a study protocol

An exploratory data-driven approach to classify subgroups of patients with temporomandibular disorders based on pain mechanisms

Application of the grading system for "nociplastic pain" in chronic primary and chronic secondary pain conditions: a field study

Prognostic subgroups of chronic pain patients using latent variable mixture modeling within a supervised machine learning framework