Machine Learning to Predict-Then-Optimize Elective Orthopaedic Surgery Scheduling Improves Operating Room Utilization

Johnathan R. Lex,Jacob Mosseri,Jay Toor,Aazad Abbas,Michael Simone,Bheeshma Ravi,Cari Whyne,Elias B. Khalil
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.10.24311370
2024-08-11
Abstract:Objective: To determine the potential for improving elective surgery scheduling for total knee and hip arthroplasty (TKA and THA, respectively) by utilizing a two-stage approach that incorporates machine learning (ML) prediction of the duration of surgery (DOS) with scheduling optimization. Materials and Methods: Two ML models (for TKA and THA) were trained to predict DOS using patient factors based on 302,490 and 196,942 examples, respectively, from a large international database. Three optimization formulations based on varying surgeon flexibility were compared: Any- surgeons could operate in any operating room at any time, Split- limitation of two surgeons per operating room per day, and MSSP- limit of one surgeon per operating room per day. Two years of daily scheduling simulations were performed for each optimization problem using ML-prediction or mean DOS over a range of schedule parameters. Constraints and resources were based on a high volume arthroplasty hospital in Canada. Results: The Any scheduling formulation performed significantly worse than the Split and MSSP formulations with respect to overtime and underutilization (p<0.001). The latter two problems performed similarly (p>0.05) over most schedule parameters. The ML-prediction schedules outperformed those generated using a mean DOS over all schedule parameters, with overtime reduced on average by 300 to 500 minutes per week. Using a 15-minute schedule granularity with a wait list pool of minimum 1 month generated the best schedules. Conclusion: Assuming a full waiting list, optimizing an individual surgeons elective operating room time using an ML-assisted predict-then optimize scheduling system improves overall operating room efficiency, significantly decreasing overtime.
Orthopedics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of improving the operating room scheduling efficiency for elective joint replacement surgeries (including total knee arthroplasty and total hip arthroplasty, abbreviated as TKA and THA) by combining machine learning (ML) to predict the duration of surgery (DOS) with scheduling optimization. Specifically, the study aims to: 1. **Reduce operating room overtime**: By optimizing surgery schedules, reduce the use of operating rooms beyond working hours, thereby lowering hospital operating costs. 2. **Improve operating room utilization**: Ensure that operating rooms are fully utilized during working hours to avoid resource wastage. 3. **Evaluate the effectiveness of different scheduling methods**: Compare three different scheduling optimization models (Any, Split, and MSSP) to determine which method performs best in reducing overtime and improving utilization. To achieve these goals, the researchers developed two machine learning models to predict the surgery times for TKA and THA and used these predictions to generate weekly simulated surgery schedules. By comparing schedules generated using average surgery times, the study evaluated the effectiveness of combining machine learning predictions with scheduling optimization. The results showed that schedules using machine learning predictions performed better under most parameter combinations, reducing overtime by an average of 300 to 500 minutes per week. However, this approach also led to a certain degree of decline in operating room utilization.