Abstract:The structural credit assignment problem arises when the causal structure between actions and subsequent outcomes is hidden from direct observation. To solve this problem and enable goal-directed behavior, an agent has to infer structure and form a representation thereof. In the scope of this study, we investigate a possible solution in the human brain. We recorded behavioral and electrophysiological data from human participants in a novel variant of the bandit task, where multiple actions lead to multiple outcomes. Crucially, the mapping between actions and outcomes was hidden and not instructed to the participants. Human choice behavior revealed clear hallmarks of credit assignment and learning. Moreover, a computational model which formalizes action selection as the competition between multiple representations of the hidden structure was fit to account for participants data. Starting in a state of uncertainty about the correct representation, the central mechanism of this model is the arbitration of action control towards the representation which minimizes surprise about outcomes. Crucially, single-trial latent-variable analysis reveals that the neural patterns clearly support central quantitative predictions of this surprise minimization model. The results suggest that neural activity is not only related to reinforcement learning under correct as well as incorrect task representations but also reflects central mechanisms of credit assignment and behavioral arbitration. In naturalistic environments, causal relationships between actions and their consequences are often hidden from direct observation. To overcome this structural credit-assignment problem, agents have to infer causal structures from experience. Here, we developed a computational model which formalizes action selection as the competition between structural representations, while action control is arbitrated towards the representation that minimizes surprise over time. To validate this model, we recorded behavioral and electrophysiological data from human participants in a novel task in which independent decisions are followed by outcomes, whereby the decision-outcome mapping is unknown. The model could account for patterns of choice behavior revealing clear hallmarks of credit assignment. Model-based analysis of EEG activity confirmed central model characteristics of concurrent prediction errors and a signature of evidence accumulation and behavioral arbitration. These findings highlight a key role of surprise minimization for both value and representation learning and reveal neural correlates of credit assignment.

Neural mechanisms of credit assignment for delayed outcomes during contingent learning

The neural substrates of probabilistic and intertemporal decision making

Prefrontal signals precede striatal signals for biased credit assignment in motivational learning biases

Neural activity ramps in frontal cortex signal extended motivation during learning

Agency rescues competition for credit assignment among predictive cues from adverse learning conditions

Surprise-minimization as a solution to the structural credit assignment problem

Selective Credit Assignment

Cognitive mechanisms of learning in sequential decision-making under uncertainty: an experimental and theoretical approach

Differential phase-amplitude coupling in nucleus accumbens and orbitofrontal cortex reflects decision-making during a delay discounting task

Parallel Contributions of Distinct Human Memory Systems During Probabilistic Learning.

Neural dynamics in the orbitofrontal cortex reveal cognitive strategies

Linking Brain Electrical Signals Elicited by Current Outcomes with Future Risk Decision-Making

Anterior Cingulate Cortex Causally Supports Meta-Learning

Sunk Cost Effects Hinge on the Neural Recalibration of Reference Points in Mental Accounting

A computational model of behavioral adaptation to solve the credit assignment problem

Policy adjustment in a dynamic economic game

Neural representations of the amount and the delay time of reward in intertemporal decision making

How Instructed Knowledge Modulates the Neural Systems of Reward Learning

Overlapping and Distinct Neural Systems Code for Subjective Value during Intertemporal and Risky Decision Making

Coordinated cross-brain activity during accumulation of sensory evidence and decision commitment

Partially dissociable roles of the Orbitofrontal cortex and dorsal Hippocampus in context-dependent (hierarchical) reward predictions and contextual inference in learning