Abstract:Phenotypic variability in isogenic bacterial populations is a remarkable feature that helps them cope with external stresses, yet it is incompletely understood. This variability can stem from gene expression noise and/or unequal partitioning of low-copy-number freely diffusing proteins during cell division. Some high-copy-number components are transiently associated with almost immobile large assemblies (hyperstructures) and may be unequally distributed, contributing to bacterial phenotypic variability. We focus on the nucleoid hyperstructure containing numerous DNA-associated proteins, including the replication initiator DnaA. Previously we found an increasing asynchrony in the nucleoid segregation dynamics in growing E. coli cell lineages and suggested that variable replication initiation timing may be the main cause of this phenomenon. Here we support this hypothesis revealing that DnaA/DNA variability represents a key factor leading to the enhanced asynchrony in E. coli. We followed the intra- and intercellular distribution of fluorescently tagged DnaA and histone-like HU chromosomally encoded under their native promoters. The diffusion rate of DnaA is low, corresponding to a diffusion-binding mode of mobility, but still one order faster than that of HU. The intracellular distribution of DnaA concentration is homogeneous in contrast to the significant asymmetry in the distribution of HU to the cell halves, leading to unequal DNA content of nucleoids and DnaA/DNA ratios in future daughter compartments. Accordingly, the intercellular variabilities of HU concentration (CV=26%) and DnaA/DNA ratio (CV=18%) are high. The variable DnaA/DNA may cause a variable replication initiation time (initiation noise). Asynchronous initiation at different replication origins may, in turn, be the mechanism leading to the observed asymmetric intracellular DNA distribution. Our findings indicate that the feature determining the variability of initiation time in E. coli is the DnaA/DNA ratio rather than separately each of them. We provide a likely mechanism for the "loss of segregation synchrony" phenomenon.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the source of phenotypic variability in isogenic bacterial populations. Specifically, the researchers focused on how the relative distribution of DnaA protein and DNA in Escherichia coli cells affects the phenotypic variability of the cells, especially how this distribution leads to the inconsistency in the replication initiation time during cell division, and further affects the asymmetric separation of the nucleoid. ### Background of the paper and the core of the problem 1. **Significance of phenotypic variability**: - Bacteria show high phenotypic flexibility in the face of external pressure, which helps them cope with environmental changes, especially in cases such as antibiotic exposure. - However, this phenotypic variability has not been fully understood. 2. **Existing theories**: - Gene expression noise and unequal distribution of low - copy - number freely diffusing proteins during cell division are considered the main sources of phenotypic variability. - But these theories ignore certain high - copy - number components, which may be temporarily or permanently associated with large, almost immobile assemblies (superstructures), resulting in unequal distribution. 3. **Research focus**: - This study focuses on the nucleoid superstructure containing numerous DNA - related proteins, especially the replication initiation factor DnaA. - Previous studies have found that after 2 - 3 divisions in Escherichia coli cell lines, the dynamics of nucleoid separation gradually become asynchronous, and it is speculated that the change in replication initiation time may be the main reason for this phenomenon. ### Specific problems - **Distribution of DnaA and DNA**: - The researchers studied the distribution of DnaA and histone - like HU in cells and their changes during cell division by fluorescently labeling DnaA and HU. - It was found that the diffusion rate of DnaA is low, but still one order of magnitude faster than that of HU, resulting in a relatively uniform distribution of DnaA in the cell, while HU is unevenly distributed between the two halves of the cell. - **Variability of DnaA/DNA ratio**: - The variability of the DnaA/DNA ratio is high (the coefficient of variation is 18%), which may lead to the inconsistency in replication initiation time (initiation noise). - Asynchronous initiation times may further lead to asynchronous start - up at different replication origins, thus causing the observed asymmetry in the intracellular DNA distribution. ### Conclusions - **Importance of DnaA/DNA ratio**: - The research results show that the important factor determining the variability of replication initiation time in Escherichia coli is the DnaA/DNA ratio, rather than the individual DnaA or DNA concentration. - This finding provides a possible mechanism to explain the "loss of division synchrony" phenomenon. In summary, this paper reveals how these factors affect the phenotypic variability of cells, especially their roles in replication initiation time and nucleoid separation, through a detailed study of the distribution and variability of DnaA and DNA in Escherichia coli cells.

Relative Distribution of DnaA and DNA in Escherichia coli Cells as a Factor of Their Phenotypic Variability

DnaA and the timing of chromosome replication in Escherichia coli as a function of growth rate

Low Affinity DnaA-ATP Recognition Sites in E. coli oriC Make Non-equivalent and Growth Rate-Dependent Contributions to the Regulated Timing of Chromosome Replication

The Escherichia coli replication initiator DnaA is titrated on the chromosome

Robust control of replication initiation in the absence of DnaA-ATP ↔ DnaA-ADP regulatory elements in

Compaction and Segregation of DNA in Escherichia coli

Effect of Replication Fork Dynamics on Escherichia coli Cell Size

Fluctuations in growth rates determine the generation time and size distributions of E. coli cells

Threshold effect of growth rate on population variability of Escherichia coli cell lengths

Robust replication initiation from coupled homeostatic mechanisms

DNA-polymer architecture orchestrates the segregation and spatio-temporal organization of E. coli chromosomes during replication in slow growth

A nucleoid-associated protein is involved in the emergence of antibiotic resistance by promoting the frequent exchange of the replicative DNA polymerase in

DNA/polysome phase separation and cell width confinement couple nucleoid segregation to cell growth in Escherichia coli

Links between Transcription, Environmental Adaptation and Gene Variability in Escherichia coli: Correlations between Gene Expression and Gene Variability Reflect Growth Efficiencies.

The Bacterial Nucleoid: From Electron Microscopy to Polymer Physics—A Personal Recollection

DNA replication initiation timing is important for maintaining genome integrity

Physical heterogeneity among Bacillus subtilis deoxyribonucleic acid molecules carrying particular genetic markers

Cell Size Is Coordinated with Cell Cycle by Regulating Initiator Protein DnaA in E. coli

Read-through transcription of tRNA underlies the cell cycle-dependent dissociation of IHF from the DnaA-inactivating sequence datA

Heterogeneity of Subcellular Diffusion in Bacteria Based on Spatial Segregation of Ribosomes and Nucleoids

The limiting DNA replication initiation factors Sld2 and Sld3 influence origin efficiency independent of origin firing time