An eye-tracking study of visual attention in chimpanzees and bonobos when viewing different tool-using techniques

Yige Piao,James Brooks,Shinya Yamamoto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.01.605994

2024-08-01

Abstract:Chimpanzees and bonobos are excellent tool users and can socially learn various skills. Previous studies on social learning mainly measure success/failure in acquiring new techniques, with less direct measurement of proximate mechanisms like visual attention during the process. This study investigates how apes observe tool-using demonstrations through eye-tracking. After checking initial techniques, six chimpanzees and six bonobos were shown video demonstrations of human demonstrators using a tube to dip (low-efficiency) or suck (high-efficiency) juice, and then tried the task themselves. Attention to each video was compared to participants' knowledge. Although no individuals acquired the high-efficiency technique through video demonstrations, eye-tracking results revealed attentional differences between individuals familiar with different techniques. Compared with individuals already familiar with both techniques, individuals knowing only the dipping technique showed less attention to the unfamiliar sucking technique. This result indicates that apes may not attend much to what they do not know well, which aligns with reported interplay of action observation and understanding. Attentional patterns to specific areas was similar between species, though there was a tendency towards more attention to faces in bonobos and food in chimpanzees. This study emphasizes the importance of detailed investigation into social learning process using eye-tracking.

Animal Behavior and Cognition

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the visual attention characteristics of chimpanzees and bonobos when observing demonstrations of tool use. The study uses eye-tracking technology to analyze how these two closely related species allocate their attention while watching humans demonstrate two different tool-use techniques (an inefficient dipping method and an efficient sucking method).

### Research Questions

The core question this study aims to address is: How does the visual attention of chimpanzees and bonobos change when observing tool-use demonstrations that are either similar to or different from their known techniques? Specifically, the study focuses on the following points:

1. **Impact of Different Baseline Techniques**: The difference in attention participants pay to different techniques (known vs. unknown).
2. **Inter-species Differences**: Potential differences in attention allocation between chimpanzees and bonobos.
3. **Possibility of Technique Transfer**: Whether individuals using a specific technique (such as the inefficient dipping method) can notice a more efficient technique (such as the sucking method) and subsequently attempt to adopt the more efficient method.

### Main Findings

- **Attention Differences**: The study found that individuals who already knew the efficient sucking technique paid closer attention to the demonstration videos of the efficient sucking technique compared to those who only knew the inefficient dipping technique.
- **Similarities and Differences Between Species**: Chimpanzees and bonobos exhibited similar patterns in focusing on the action parts (i.e., the tool-use process); however, bonobos showed marginally longer attention to human faces.
- **Technique Transfer**: Although no individuals in the study learned the more efficient sucking technique through video demonstrations, this result provides valuable insights into attention allocation during the social learning process.

In summary, this study reveals the attention patterns of chimpanzees and bonobos when observing tool-use demonstrations through eye-tracking technology and provides important clues for further exploration of social learning mechanisms.