Comparative lifespan and healthspan of nonhuman primate species common to biomedical research

Hillary F Huber,Hannah C Ainsworth,Ellen E Quillen,Adam Salmon,Corinna Ross,Adinda D Azhar,Karen Bales,Michele A Basso,Kristine Coleman,Ricki Colman,Huda S Darusman,Bill Hopkins,Charlotte E Hotchkiss,Matthew J Jorgensen,Kylie Kavanagh,Cun Li,Julie A Mattison,Peter W Nathanielsz,Suryo Saputro,Diana G Scorpio,Paul-Michael Sosa,Eric J Vallender,Yaomin Wang,Caroline J Zeiss,Carol A Shively,Laura A Cox

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.31.606010

2024-08-06

Abstract:There is a critical need to generate age- and sex-specific survival curves to characterize chronological aging consistently across nonhuman primates (NHP) used in biomedical research. Accurate measures of chronological aging are essential for inferences into genetic, demographic, and physiological variables driving differences in NHP lifespan within and between species. Understanding NHP lifespans is relevant to public health because unraveling the demographic, molecular, and clinical bases of health across the life course in translationally relevant NHP species is fundamentally important to the study of human aging. Data from more than 110,000 captive individual NHP were contributed by 15 major research institutions to generate sex-specific Kaplan-Meier survival curves using uniform methods in 12 translational aging models: Callithrix jacchus (common marmoset), Chlorocebus aethiops sabaeus (vervet/African green), Macaca fascicularis (cynomolgus macaque), M. fuscata (Japanese macaque), M. mulatta (rhesus macaque), M. nemestrina (pigtail macaque), M. radiata (bonnet macaque), Pan troglodytes spp. (chimpanzee), Papio hamadryas spp. (baboon), Plecturocebus cupreus (coppery titi monkey), Saguinus oedipus (cotton-top tamarin), and Saimiri spp. (squirrel monkey). After employing strict inclusion criteria, primary analysis results are based on 12,269 NHP that survived to adulthood and died of natural/health-related causes. A secondary analysis was completed for 32,616 NHP that died of any cause. For the primary analyses, we report ages of 25th, 50th, 75th, and 85th percentiles of survival, maximum observed ages, rates of survivorship, and sex-based differences captured by quantile regression models and Kolmogorov-Smirnov tests. Our findings show a pattern of reduced male survival among catarrhines (African and Asian primates), especially macaques, but not platyrrhines (Central and South American primates). For many species, median lifespans were lower than previously reported. An important consideration is that these analyses may offer a better reflection of healthspan than lifespan. Captive NHP used in research are typically euthanized for humane welfare reasons before their natural end of life, often after diagnosis of their first major disease requiring long-term treatment with reduced quality of life (e.g., endometriosis, cancer, osteoarthritis). Supporting the idea that these data are capturing healthspan, for several species typical age at onset of chronic disease is similar to the median lifespan estimates. This data resource represents the most comprehensive characterization of sex-specific lifespan and age-at-death distributions for 12 biomedically relevant species, to date. The results clarify the relationships among NHP ages and will provide a valuable resource for the aging research community, improving human-NHP age equivalencies, informing investigators of the expected survival rates of NHP assigned to studies, providing a metric for comparisons in future studies, and contributing to our understanding of the factors that drive lifespan differences within and among species.

Physiology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main objective of this paper is to generate age- and sex-specific survival curves for non-human primates (NHPs) used in biomedical research, characterizing the lifespan of these animals in a consistent manner. Specifically, the research team collected data from over 110,000 captive non-human primates from 15 major research institutions to construct Kaplan-Meier survival curves for 12 species used as models in aging research. These 12 species include:

- Common marmoset (*Callithrix jacchus*)
- African green monkey (*Chlorocebus aethiops sabaeus*)
- Cynomolgus monkey (*Macaca fascicularis*)
- Japanese macaque (*M. fuscata*)
- Rhesus macaque (*M. mulatta*)
- Pig-tailed macaque (*M. nemestrina*)
- Bonnet macaque (*M. radiata*)
- Chimpanzee (*Pan troglodytes* spp.)
- Hamadryas baboon (*Papio hamadryas* spp.)
- Coppery titi monkey (*Plecturocebus cupreus*)
- Cotton-top tamarin (*Saguinus oedipus*)
- Squirrel monkey (*Saimiri* spp.)

The research focuses include:

1. **Lifespan vs. Healthspan**: The study distinguishes between "lifespan" and "healthspan," noting that most research NHPs are euthanized for humane reasons before natural death, thus the data more accurately reflect healthspan rather than lifespan.

2. **Sex Differences**: The analysis examined the impact of sex on survival rates across different species, finding that male individuals had lower survival rates in some species, particularly in Old World monkeys, whereas this sex difference was less pronounced in New World monkeys.

3. **Methodological Consistency**: By employing a unified approach to data handling, cross-species comparisons were made possible, providing the most comprehensive description to date of sex-specific lifespan and age-at-death distributions for these species.

4. **Data Quality Control**: Through stringent data screening criteria, the final analysis dataset included only individuals that died naturally or were euthanized for health reasons after reaching adulthood.

The study's results indicate that the median lifespan of many species is lower than previously reported estimates and reveal significant differences between species and between sexes within the same species. Additionally, the research discusses factors influencing lifespan, such as reproductive strategies and levels of veterinary care, and explores the potential correlations between the survival curves of captive NHPs and human healthspan.