Quantifying synthetic bacterial community composition with flow cytometry: efficacy in mock communities and challenges in co-cultures

Fabian Mermans,Ioanna Chatzigiannidou,Wim Teughels,Nico Boon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.26.605308

2024-07-26

Abstract:Determination of bacterial community composition in synthetic communities is critical for understanding microbial systems. The community composition is typically determined through bacterial plating or through PCR-based methods which can be labor-intensive, expensive or prone to bias. Simultaneously, flow cytometry has been suggested as a cheap and fast alternative. However, since the technique captures the phenotypic state of bacterial cells, accurate determination of community composition could be affected when bacteria are co-cultured. We investigated the performance of flow cytometry for quantifying oral synthetic communities and compared it to the performance of strain specific qPCR and 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing. Therefore, axenic cultures, mock communities and co-cultures of oral bacteria were prepared. Random forest classifiers trained on flow cytometry data of axenic cultures were used to determine the composition of the synthetic communities, as well as strain specific qPCR and 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing. Flow cytometry was shown to have a lower average root mean squared error and outperformed the PCR-based methods in even mock communities (flow cytometry: 0.11 ± 0.04; qPCR: 0.26 ± 0.09; amplicon sequencing: 0.15 ± 0.01). When bacteria were co-cultured, neither flow cytometry, strain specific qPCR and 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing resulted in similar community composition. Performance of flow cytometry was decreased compared to mock communities due to changing phenotypes. Finally, discrepancies between flow cytometry and strain specific qPCR were found. These findings highlight the challenges ahead for quantifying community composition in co-cultures by flow cytometry.

Microbiology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily aims to address the following issues:

### Research Background and Objectives

- **Problems with Traditional Methods**: Determining the composition of synthetic bacterial communities typically relies on bacterial plate counts or PCR-based methods (such as specific qPCR and 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing), which are often time-consuming, expensive, and may introduce biases.
- **Flow Cytometry as an Alternative**: Flow cytometry has been proposed as a potential tool for quantifying microbial community composition due to its rapidity, cost-effectiveness, and ability to provide multi-parameter optical data at the single-cell level.

### Specific Research Questions

- **Application of Flow Cytometry in Simulated Communities**: Investigate whether flow cytometry can effectively quantify the relative and absolute composition of oral synthetic communities, particularly for simple simulated communities.
- **Performance Evaluation under Co-culture Challenges**: Assess how the accuracy and reliability of flow cytometry in quantifying community composition change when bacteria are under co-culture conditions.
- **Comparison with PCR-based Methods**: Compare the performance of flow cytometry with specific qPCR and 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing in quantifying synthetic community composition.

### Overview of Experimental Design

- Various oral bacteria were used in the experiments.
- Prepared pure cultures, simulated communities (including homogeneous and heterogeneous combinations), and co-cultures.
- Trained flow cytometry data using a random forest classifier to predict community composition.
- Comparative analysis of results from flow cytometry, specific qPCR, and 16S rRNA gene amplicon sequencing.

### Key Findings

- Flow cytometry performed well in simple simulated communities but faced challenges in co-cultures due to changes in bacterial phenotypes.
- In homogeneous simulated communities, flow cytometry performed better than or comparable to PCR-based methods.
- For heterogeneous simulated communities, specific qPCR results were closer to theoretical values.
- In terms of absolute quantification, cell concentrations obtained by flow cytometry were lower than qPCR results, possibly due to the presence of cell aggregates.

In summary, this paper explores the potential and limitations of flow cytometry as a novel tool for quantifying the composition of synthetic bacterial communities and provides an in-depth analysis of its performance under different conditions.