Differential biotransformation ability may alter fish biodiversity in polluted waters

Marco E Franco,Juliane Hollender,Kristin Schirmer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.26.605280

2024-07-26

Abstract:Divergence in the activity of biotransformation pathways could lead to species sensitivity differences to chemical stress. To explore this hypothesis, we evaluated the biotransformation capacity of five fish species that are representatives of Swiss biodiversity assemblages and that inhabit watercourses surrounded by different land use. We report important interspecific differences regarding the presence and activity of major biotransformation pathways, such as the invasive pumpinkseed (Lepomis gibbosus) displaying micropollutant clearance between 3- and 7-fold higher than native species (e.g. Salmo trutta, Squalius cephalus) collected in the same areas. These differences were exacerbated by urban and agricultural influence, which increased biotransformation potential at the enzyme level by as much as 11-fold and micropollutant clearance by approximately 2-fold compared to biotransformation levels in areas with minimal human influence. In the context of the chemical defensome, we argue that fish with low biotransformation activity carry a greater burden on chemical stress, making them less likely to cope with additional stressors and sustain their population in competition with species with a higher biotransformation capacity.

Pharmacology and Toxicology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the impact of biotransformation capacity on the biodiversity of fish in polluted water bodies. The core issue of the study is to investigate the differences in biotransformation pathways among different fish species and how these differences affect their sensitivity to chemical stress.

Specifically, the study evaluated the biotransformation capacity of 5 fish species representing Swiss biodiversity (including invasive and native species) in water bodies with different land use types. The study found:

1. **Inter-species differences in biotransformation capacity**: There are significant differences in biotransformation capacity among different fish species. For example, the invasive species—pumpkinseed (Lepomis gibbosus) has a 3 to 7 times higher capacity to eliminate micropollutants compared to other native fish species (such as brown trout Salmo trutta and chub Squalius cephalus).

2. **Changes influenced by human activities**: Urban and agricultural activities exacerbate these differences, increasing the biotransformation potential of fish in polluted areas by up to 11 times at the enzyme level and approximately 2 times in terms of micropollutant elimination.

3. **Impact from the perspective of chemical defense systems**: The authors suggest that in the context of chemical defense systems, fish with lower biotransformation activity may bear a greater chemical stress burden, making it more difficult for them to cope with additional stressors and maintain their populations when competing with species with higher biotransformation capacity.

In summary, this study aims to reveal the differences in sensitivity to chemical pollution among different fish species by analyzing their biotransformation capacities and further explore how these differences affect the survival ability and biodiversity patterns of fish in polluted environments.