Meta-analysis of spatial genetic patterns among European saproxylic beetles - the influence of history and contemporary forest quality

Rama S Krovi,Nermeen Amer,Lukasz Kajtoch,Maria Oczkowicz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.24.604895

2024-07-24

Abstract:The phylogeography of forest-dwelling species in Europe is well understood, although our knowledge regarding the genetics of saproxylic beetles remains insufficient. This knowledge gap extends to understanding the influence of both quaternary history and contemporary forest dynamics on population genetics. To fill this gap, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of recent literature concerning saproxylic beetle taxa with available genetic data. We include both threatened and common species in our study which enabled us to generalize our findings to the whole saproxylic community. Results suggest a latitudinal decrease in diversity in most species, likely influenced by Pleistocene glaciation and subsequent population expansions from southern refugia. Additionally, we observed an east-west gradient in diversity, with threatened species exhibiting higher diversity towards the east. This may reflect historical forest dynamics and anthropogenic pressures, such as heavy wood logging in Western Europe. Similarly, we found a pattern along altitude, with populations in higher elevation forests, 26 which are often more natural, exhibiting higher diversity. Furthermore, we identified distinct phylogenetic units or genetic clusters in southern Europe reflecting the distribution of glacial refugia. For some taxa, distinct units were also reported in eastern Europe where populations spread from Asian refugia. Central Europe showed a high number of phylogenetic units, although unique (private) clades or clusters were absent. Most likely it is an effect of the presence of beetles that originated from various refugia belonging to different phylogenetic units. This study brings insights into general phylogeographic patterns, which have previously been examined only for single representatives of saproxylic beetles. It should also help in the proper planning of conservation and management efforts of wood-dwelling beetles.

Genetics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the spatial distribution patterns and influencing factors of genetic diversity in European saproxylic beetle populations. Specifically, the authors explore the following aspects through systematic review and meta-analysis:

1. **Changes in genetic diversity with latitude**: It is hypothesized that the genetic diversity of saproxylic beetle populations decreases from south to north, similar to the situation for most European forest-dwelling species.
2. **Changes in genetic diversity with longitude**: It is hypothesized that for northern forest species, eastern populations have higher genetic polymorphism because these areas are less affected by glaciation.
3. **Changes in genetic diversity with altitude**: It is hypothesized that populations in high-altitude areas have higher genetic diversity because the forests in these regions are less affected by timber harvesting.
4. **Number and distribution of genetic units**: The number and distribution of genetic units (such as mitochondrial lineages or microsatellite clusters) are compared between different species to find general patterns that may have important implications for forest conservation and management.
5. **Comparison of genetic diversity between rare species and pest species**: It is hypothesized that the overall genetic polymorphism of rare species is lower than that of pest species because the latter are less affected by forest management measures.

Through these studies, the authors hope to provide a scientific basis for the effective planning of conservation for rare and threatened species, as well as the management of economically valuable species, and to provide background information for future research on the genetic variation of saproxylic beetles.