Clarifying misconceptions of biomolecular condensate formation

Nidhi Hosamane,McKayla Hartman,Matt Dubach

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.17.603945

2024-07-19

Abstract:Biomolecular condensates are liquid-like phase separations of disordered proteins and other molecules within cells. These membrane-less organelles are essential in critical cellular processes and are aberrant in myriad disease. Yet, the thermodynamics of condensate formation are not entirely understood, thus the mechanisms of condensate function remain elusive. Two assumptions about biomolecular condensates are that they form through liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) and require multivalent interactions. Here, we show results and propose thermodynamic frameworks that suggest these assumptions are not always correct. We demonstrate that condensation does not follow canonical LLPS and that liquid-like phase separation can arise from monovalent interactions. These results clarify the mechanism of condensate thermodynamics to reframe our understanding of condensates in cellular function and disease.

Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the two main hypotheses in the formation mechanism of biomolecular condensates are correct. Specifically:

1. **Liquid - Liquid Phase Separation (LLPS) Hypothesis**: The traditional view holds that the formation of biomolecular condensates follows the thermodynamic laws of liquid - liquid phase separation. According to this hypothesis, when the total system concentration exceeds a certain saturation concentration \(C_{\text{sat}}\), liquid - liquid phase separation will occur, and when the total concentration reaches the concentration of the high - density phase \(C_{\text{den}}\), the phase separation disappears and the system is in a uniform high - density phase. Between \(C_{\text{sat}}\) and \(C_{\text{den}}\), the phase - separated state has the lowest energy, producing a high - concentration dense phase and a low - concentration sparse phase. In this case, the partition coefficient of phase separation (i.e., the ratio of the concentrations in the dense and sparse phases) is constant at all total protein concentrations where phase separation occurs and does not depend on the total concentration.

2. **Multivalent Interaction Hypothesis**: Another hypothesis is that the formation of biomolecular condensates requires multivalent interactions. Long disordered proteins can have multiple interactions with several other molecules, and such multivalent interactions keep the condensates stable at equilibrium.

Through experimental and theoretical analyses, the paper challenges these two hypotheses. The authors find that:

- The formation of biomolecular condensates does not fully follow the classical liquid - liquid phase separation laws, and its partition coefficient is actually a function of the total concentration rather than being constant.
- Liquid - liquid phase separation can be achieved through monovalent interactions, not just multivalent interactions.

These findings are of great significance for understanding the formation mechanism of biomolecular condensates and their roles in cell functions and diseases. By re - considering the thermodynamic model of condensates and removing incorrect constraints, the formation mechanism of condensates can be better explained and new perspectives can be provided for related research.