'It does help but there is a limit': Young people's perspectives on policies that restrict hot food takeaways opening near schools

Bea Savory,Claire Thompson,Suzan Hassan,Jean Adams,Ben Amies-Cull,Daniel Derbyshire,Michael Chang,Matthew Keeble,Bochu Liu,Antonieta Medina-Lara,Oliver Mytton,John Rahilly,Nina Rogers,Richard Smith,Martin White,Thomas Burgoine,Steven Cummins

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.17.24310555

2024-07-18

Abstract:Background: Local authorities (LAs) in England are increasingly using the planning system to control the proliferation of hot food takeaway outlets (takeaways) near schools as part of a range of policies to promote healthy weight in children. These takeaway management zones (TMZs) include restrictions on planning permission to open new takeaways within a certain distance of a school. In this qualitative study we explore young peoples perspectives of TMZs. Methods: We purposively recruited 46 young people (aged 11-18 years old) attending secondary school across two contrasting London LAs with operating TMZs. We conducted semi-structured, walking group interviews (go-alongs) in January-February 2023 in the local food environment close to participant schools. We analysed data using framework analysis. Results: Participants generally viewed TMZs as reasonable and uncontroversial but were not always aware that TMZs were in operation. Although participants understood that TMZs prevented new outlets from opening, they observed they did not seem to reduce existing provision. This was viewed positively as it did not result in the closure of local takeaways perceived as important components of the social fabric of school life. Participants believed that the potential health impact of TMZs is limited by their exclusive focus on takeaways as other food retail commonly patronised by young people, such as convenience stores, are important sources of unhealthy food. Participants also identified inadequacies in the wider food environment, including the school dining environment and access to food delivery apps. Conclusions: Our findings suggest that although young people find TMZs acceptable and believe they have some positive impact on diet, they did not perceive TMZs as effective as they could be. Participants articulated that the management of takeaways on their own is unlikely to reduce exposure to unhealthy foods. Widening the remit of planning policy to include outlets selling convenience foods may be important for policy optimisation.

Public and Global Health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores young people's views and attitudes towards the policy of restricting the opening of hot food takeaway shops (hereinafter referred to as "takeaway shops") near schools. The research background is that local governments in the UK control the number of takeaway shops near schools through the planning system as part of a strategy to promote healthy weight among children. These so-called "Takeaway Management Zones" (TMZs) include regulations that limit the opening of new takeaway shops within a certain distance. The paper uses qualitative research methods to explore young people's attitudes towards these policies, perceived effects, and factors that may influence policy implementation.

### Main Findings

1. **Acceptance**: Participants generally considered the Takeaway Management Zones to be reasonable and uncontroversial, but they were not always aware that these policies were being implemented. While they understood that these policies prevented new takeaway shops from opening, they observed that these policies did not seem to reduce the number of existing takeaway shops. This phenomenon was viewed positively because it did not lead to the closure of popular local takeaway shops, which were seen as an important part of the social structure of school life.

2. **Limited Effectiveness**: Participants believed that the impact of the Takeaway Management Zones was limited because they focused solely on the takeaway shops themselves, ignoring other retail points selling unhealthy food, such as convenience stores, which are also frequented by young people. Additionally, they pointed out shortcomings in the broader food environment, including the school dining environment and the prevalence of takeaway apps.

3. **Policy Recommendations**: The study concluded that although young people found the Takeaway Management Zones acceptable and believed these measures had some positive impact on dietary habits, they did not feel that these policies were very effective. Participants indicated that merely managing takeaway shops was not enough to reduce opportunities to access unhealthy food. Therefore, expanding the scope of planning policies to include stores selling convenience foods could be very important for optimizing the policy.

In summary, the paper aims to understand young students' views on the Takeaway Management Zones policy and its actual impact on dietary behavior, thereby providing a reference for future policy-making.