Predictive value of blood eosinophils and exhaled nitric oxide in adults with mild asthma: a prespecified subgroup analysis of an open-label, parallel-group, randomised controlled trial
Ian D Pavord,Mark Holliday,Helen K Reddel,Irene Braithwaite,Stefan Ebmeier,Robert J Hancox,Tim Harrison,Claire Houghton,Karen Oldfield,Alberto Papi,Mathew Williams,Mark Weatherall,Richard Beasley,Novel START Study Team,Andrew Corin,Colin Helm,Bhuwan Poudel,Davitt Sheahan,Pamela Sheahan,Miriam Bennett,Caterina Chang,Hollie Ellis,Bob Hancox,Sandra Hopping,Christine Tuffery,James Michael Ramsahai,Jodie Simpson,Peter Wark,Maria Aliani,Maddalena Genco,Alberto Capozzolo,Mauro Carone,Elisa Maini,Jenny Mancin,Antonio Meriggi,Luca Perfetti,Francesca Cherubino,Antonio Spanevello,Dina Visca,Elisabetta Zampogna,Christina Baggott,Allie Eathorne,James Fingleton,Jo Hardy,Janine Pilcher,Donah Sabbagh,Alex Semprini,Karen Shaw,Summer Mackisack,Barney Montgomery,Karen Autridge,Joanna Joseph,Stella Moon,Dean Quinn,Dean Millar-Coote,Jim Reid,Federico Bellini,Martina Marchi,Luca Morandi,Marianna Padovani,Daniela Scalet,Katie Borg,Clare Connolly,Anna Gittins,Gareth Hynes,Helen Jeffers,Ian Pavord,Rahul Shrimanker,Gloria Foxley,Elyse Guevara-Rattray,Stephen Milne,Helen Reddel,Brett Toelle
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S2213-2600(20)30053-9
Abstract:Background: Whether blood eosinophil counts and exhaled nitric oxide (FeNO) are associated with important outcomes in mild asthma is unclear. In this prespecified subgroup analysis of a previously published open-label clinical trial, we aimed to assess associations between blood eosinophil counts and FeNO with outcomes and response to asthma treatment. Methods: In the previously reported 52-week, open-label, randomised controlled trial, people with mild asthma receiving only β agonist reliever inhalers were enrolled at one of 16 clinical trials units in New Zealand, the UK, Italy, or Australia. Eligible participants were randomly assigned (1:1:1, stratified by country), to receive inhalers to take as-needed salbutamol (two inhalations of 100 μg in a pressurised metered dose inhaler), maintenance budesonide (200 μg twice per day by inhaler) plus as-needed salbutamol (two inhalations of 100 μg), or as-needed budesonide-formoterol (one inhalation of 200 μg budesonide and 6μg formoterol by inhaler). The primary outcome was the annual rates of asthma exacerbations per patient, and in this prespecified subgroup analysis, we assessed whether annual exacerbation rates in each treatment group were significantly different depending on levels of blood eosinophil count, FeNO, or a composite score of both. Analyses were done for patients with available biomarker measurements The study was registered with the Australian New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry, number ACTRN12615000999538. Findings: 675 participants were enrolled between March 17, 2016, and Aug 29, 2017, of whom 656 had results for blood eosinophil analysis and 668 had results for FeNO. Of the patients who received as-needed salbutamol, the proportion of patients having a severe exacerbation increased progressively with increasing blood eosinophil count (two [4%] of 49 participants with <0·15 × 109/L, six [6%] of 93 with 0·15 to <0·3 × 109/L, and 15 [19%] of 77 with ≥0·3 × 109/L; p=0·014). There were no significant interactions between blood eosinophil count or FeNO level and the effect of as-needed budesonide-formoterol compared with as-needed salbutamol for either exacerbations or severe exacerbations. However, there were significant interactions between blood eosinophil count subgroups and the effect of maintenance budesonide plus as-needed salbutamol compared with as-needed salbutamol, both for exacerbations (p=0·0006) and severe exacerbations (p=0·0007). Maintenance budesonide plus as-needed salbutamol was more effective than as-needed salbutamol in patients with blood eosinophil counts of 0·3 × 109/L or more, both for exacerbations (rate ratio 0·13 [95% CI 0·05-0·33]) and severe exacerbations (risk odds ratio 0·11 [0·03-0·45]). This difference was not seen for blood eosinophil counts of less than 0·15 × 109/L (1·15 [0·51-1·28] for exacerbations and 5·72 [0·97-33·60] for severe exacerbations). There was no consistent interaction between treatment response and FeNO or the composite score. Interpretation: In patients with mild asthma, the effects of as-needed budesonide-formoterol on exacerbations are independent of biomarker profile, whereas the benefits of maintenance inhaled budesonide are greater in patients with high blood eosinophil counts than in patients with low counts. Funding: AstraZeneca, Health Research Council of New Zealand.