Oxford Nanopore's 2024 sequencing technology for outbreak detection and source attribution: progress and clone-specific challenges

Michael Biggel,Nicole Cernela,Jule Anna Horlbog,Roger Stephan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.12.603236

2024-07-12

Abstract:Whole genome sequencing is an essential cornerstone of pathogen surveillance and outbreak detection. Established sequencing technologies are currently challenged by Oxford Nanopore Technologies (ONT), which offers an accessible and cost-effective alternative enabling gap-free assemblies of chromosomes and plasmids. Limited accuracy has hindered its use for investigating pathogen transmission, but recent technology updates have brought significant improvements. To evaluate its readiness for outbreak detection, we selected 78 Listeria monocytogenes isolates from diverse lineages or known epidemiological clusters for sequencing with ONT's V14 Rapid Barcoding Kit and R10.4.1 flow cells. The most accurate of several tested workflows generated assemblies with a median of one error (SNP or indel) per assembly. For 66 isolates, cgMLST profiles from ONT-only assemblies were identical to those generated from Illumina data. Eight assemblies were of lower quality with more than 20 erroneous sites each, primarily caused by methylations at the GAAGAC motif (GAAG6mAC / GT4mCTTC). This led to inaccurate clustering, failing to group isolates from a persistence-associated clone that carried the responsible restriction-modification system. Out of 50 methylation motifs detected among the 78 isolates, only the GAAGAC motif was linked to substantially increased error rates. Our study shows that most L. monocytogenes genomes assembled from ONT-only data are suitable for high-resolution genotyping, but further improvements of chemistries or basecallers are required for reliable routine use in outbreak and food safety investigations.

Genomics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses the application and challenges of Oxford Nanopore's sequencing technology in the detection and tracking of Listeria monocytogenes outbreaks in 2024. The research team evaluated the performance of this technology in handling 78 different lineages or known epidemiological clusters of Listeria monocytogenes isolates, using ONT's V14 Rapid Barcoding Kit and R10.4.1 flow cell for sequencing.

Although ONT technology offers cost-effective and real-time long-read sequences, its accuracy issues limit its application in pathogen tracking. The study found that by optimizing the workflow, most assembled Listeria monocytogenes genomes are suitable for high-resolution genotyping. However, specific methylation sites (such as GAAGAC) lead to a significant increase in error rate, affecting accurate clustering of clusters, especially for persistent clones carrying the corresponding restriction modification systems.

In the paper, the researchers pointed out that ONT sequencing can generate high-quality genome assemblies in most cases, but further improvements in chemical substances or base recognition algorithms are still needed for routine use in outbreak investigation and food safety investigation to enhance reliability. In addition, they also emphasized that ONT data may lead to inaccurate genotyping and cluster analysis when handling strains carrying specific methyltransferases, which may affect the determination of transmission pathways.

In conclusion, this paper aims to determine whether ONT sequencing can provide high-quality data for the transmission tracking of Listeria monocytogenes and highlights the obstacles that need to be overcome in practical applications, especially errors related to methylation.