The flow state is not accompanied by frontal-midline theta activity: An EEG investigation of more than 700 video gameplay sessions

Hirotaka Sugino,Takuya Ideriha,Ryoichiro Yamazaki,Junichi Ushiyama

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.11.603158

2024-07-16

Abstract:People sometimes experience a "flow state"- characterized by hyperfocus, time distortion, and loss of self-awareness - during sports or video gameplay. Previous neuropsychological studies using simple laboratory tasks have reported that the flow state is associated with activation in the frontal lobe, reflected in theta (4-7 Hz) band rhythmic neural activity in medial prefrontal regions (frontal-midline theta [FMT] activity). However, the findings of previous studies might be problematic because they did not appropriately capture the neural activity associated with the flow state for the following reasons: 1) they used unfamiliar and unmotivating tasks; 2) they defined the neural basis of the flow state as neural activity occurring during tasks of optimal difficulty, disregarding trial-to-trial variations in subjective experience of the flow state; 3) the duration of the experiment or the number of trials was not sufficient to capture the rare experience of flow; or 4) they ignored individual differences in neural activities related to flow experiences. Thus, we examined the relationship between the flow state and FMT activity, recorded via scalp electroencephalography, in an experimental paradigm that addressed these four issues. First, participants played their favorite competitive video games, which they had been routinely playing. Second, task difficulty was kept as uniform as possible across trials by employing rank matching to directly examine the correlation between subjective flow level and FMT activity across trials. Third, to address the concern regarding the low frequency of the flow experience, more than 100 trials were completed over 10 days by each participant. Lastly, we adopted a within-participant statistical approach to examine individual differences in the nature of the flow experience. The results showed no correlation between FMT activity and the degree of subjective flow in six out of seven participants, contrary to previous reports. Our results challenge the conventional view that frontal lobe activity, as reflected in FMT activity, is instrumental in entering into the flow state.

Neuroscience

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the relationship between the "flow state" and frontal-midline theta (FMT) activity. The flow state refers to a psychological state of high concentration, time distortion, and loss of self-awareness experienced by individuals while performing tasks. Previous research has suggested that the flow state is associated with increased theta band EEG activity in the prefrontal region during tasks of moderate difficulty.

However, this study points out several issues with previous research: 1. The tasks used may be unfamiliar or lack motivation; 2. The neural basis of the flow state is defined as neural activity during moderately difficult tasks, ignoring the fluctuations in subjective flow experience between different trials; 3. The duration of the experiments and the number of trials are insufficient to capture the rare experience of flow; 4. The differences in neural activity related to flow experiences between individuals are overlooked.

To overcome these issues, the researchers designed an experiment where participants played their favorite video games and kept the game difficulty as consistent as possible. By using rank matching, they directly examined the relationship between subjective flow levels and FMT activity. Additionally, each participant completed over 100 game trials, and statistical methods accounting for individual differences were employed. The results showed that in 6 out of 7 participants, there was no significant correlation between FMT activity and subjective flow levels, which contradicts previous research conclusions. Therefore, this study challenges the traditional view that prefrontal activity (as reflected by FMT activity) is crucial for entering the flow state.