Landscape conservation and orchard management influence carob tree yield through changes in pollinator communities

Carmelo Gómez-Martínez,Miguel Ángel González-Estévez,Indradatta deCastro-Arrazola,Peter Unglaub,Amparo Lázaro
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.05.602169
2024-07-08
Abstract:Worldwide pollinator declines are a major problem for agricultural production. However, understanding how landscape characteristics and local management influence crop production through its pollinators is still a challenge. By sampling 20 orchards in Mallorca island (Spain), we evaluated how the landscape (habitat loss) and orchard local management (farming system: conventional vs. ecological; male-to-female ratio) influenced pollinator communities and production in carob trees (Ceratonia siliqua), a crop of high economic importance in Mediterranean areas. We found that orchards surrounded by larger natural areas received more visits by wild bees and butterflies and fewer by honeybees. Ecological farming tended to increase overall pollinator abundance in the orchards. High male-to-female ratio enhanced overall pollinator abundance and shaped pollinator composition, by increasing hoverfly abundance and decreasing wasps and flies. Male-to-female ratio showed hump-shaped relationships with fruit and seed production per female tree (peak at 0.7 males/female), whereas total orchard production maximized with 20-30% of males. Seed weight (farmer's highest economic value) increased in conserved landscapes where wild pollinators prevailed, and with overall pollinator abundance; however, it decreased with male-to-female ratio, likely due to seed number-size trade-offs. Management strategies to enhance carob production may optimize sex ratios and favor wild pollinators by reducing pesticide use and preserving natural landscapes.
Ecology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper investigates how landscape conservation and orchard management can affect the yield of carob trees (Ceratonia siliqua) by altering pollinator communities. The study was conducted in 20 orchards in Mallorca, Spain, and assessed the impacts of surrounding natural area loss, agricultural management practices (conventional vs. ecological), and the ratio of male to female trees within the orchards on pollinators and carob yield. The results show that orchards with abundant natural surroundings attract more wild bees and butterflies but fewer honeybees. Ecological agriculture tends to increase the overall number of pollinators. The ratio of male to female trees has an S-shaped relationship with fruit and seed production, peaking at a ratio of 0.7 male trees to female trees, while maximizing overall orchard yield requires 20-30% male trees. Seed weight is higher in protected landscapes dominated by wild pollinators and is positively correlated with the overall number of pollinators but negatively correlated with the male-female tree ratio. The paper suggests that to enhance carob production, promoting the survival of wild pollinators can be achieved by optimizing gender ratios, reducing pesticide use, and conserving natural landscapes. This helps mitigate the negative impacts of declining pollinators on agricultural production and achieve sustainable crop production.