Investigating associations between physical multimorbidity clusters and subsequent depression: cluster and survival analysis of UK Biobank data

Lauren Nicole DeLong,Kelly Fleetwood,Regina Prigge,Paola Galdi,Bruce Guthrie,Jacques D. Fleuriot

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.05.24310004

2024-07-07

Abstract:Background Multimorbidity, the co-occurrence of two or more conditions within an individual, is a growing challenge for health and care delivery as well as for research. Combinations of physical and mental health conditions are highlighted as particularly important. The aim of this study was to investigate associations between physical multimorbidity and subsequent depression. Methods and Findings We performed a clustering analysis upon physical morbidity data for UK Biobank participants aged 37-73 years at baseline data collection between 2006-2010. Of 502,353 participants, 142,005 had linked general practice data with at least one physical condition at baseline. Following stratification by sex (77,785 women; 64,220 men), we used four clustering methods (agglomerative hierarchical clustering, latent class analysis, k-medoids and k-modes) and selected the best-performing method based on clustering metrics. We used Fisher's Exact test to determine significant over-/under-representation of conditions within each cluster. Amongst people with no prior depression, we used survival analysis to estimate associations between cluster-membership and time to subsequent depression diagnosis. The k-modes models consistently performed best, and the over-/under-represented conditions in the resultant clusters reflected known associations. For example, clusters containing an overrepresentation of cardiometabolic conditions were amongst the largest clusters in the whole cohort (15.5% of participants, 19.7% of women, 24.2% of men). Cluster associations with depression varied from hazard ratio (HR) 1.29 (95% confidence interval (CI) 0.85-1.98) to HR 2.67 (95% CI 2.24-3.17), but almost all clusters showed a higher association with depression than those without physical conditions. Conclusions We found that certain groups of physical multimorbidity may be associated with a higher risk of subsequent depression. However, our findings invite further investigation into other factors, like social ones, which may link physical multimorbidity with depression.

Health Informatics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main objective of this paper is to explore the association between physical multimorbidity and the subsequent onset of depression. Specifically, the researchers used data from the UK Biobank to perform a cluster analysis on the multiple physical diseases present at the baseline point of the participants and further examined the relationship between these different disease combinations and the risk of subsequent depression.

The research methods include:
1. **Data Source**: A large-scale dataset from the UK Biobank was used, which includes information on participants' health status, lifestyle, and more.
2. **Cluster Analysis**: Four different clustering methods (agglomerative hierarchical clustering, latent class analysis, k-medoids, and k-modes) were used to group physical diseases, and the best-performing method (k-modes) was ultimately selected.
3. **Survival Analysis**: To assess the association between different disease combinations and subsequent depression diagnosis, the researchers also conducted survival analysis.

The main findings include:
- The k-modes clustering method performed the best in all tests.
- The study found that specific combinations of physical multimorbidity might be associated with a higher risk of subsequent depression.
- The degree of association between different disease combinations and depression varied, but almost all disease combinations showed a higher association with depression compared to individuals without physical diseases.
- As the number of physical diseases an individual has increases, their risk of subsequently developing depression also increases.

The conclusion points out that although the study found a link between certain combinations of physical multimorbidity and subsequent depression, further research is needed to explore how other factors (such as social factors) influence this relationship.