Hippocampal-entorhinal cognitive maps and cortical motor system represent action plans and their outcomes

Irina Barnaveli,Simone Vigano,Daniel Reznik,Patrick Haggard,Christian F. Doeller

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.04.602119

2024-07-05

Abstract:Efficiently interacting with the environment requires weighing and selecting among multiple alternative actions based on their associated outcomes. However, the neural mechanisms underlying these processes are still debated. We showed that forming relations between arbitrary action-outcome associations involved building a cognitive map. Using a novel immersive virtual reality paradigm, participants learned 2D abstract motor action-outcome associations and later compared action combinations while their brain activity was monitored with fMRI. We observed a hexadirectional modulation of the activity in entorhinal cortex while participants compared different action plans. Furthermore, hippocampal activity scaled with the 2D similarity between outcomes of these action plans. Conversely, the supplementary motor area (SMA) represented individual actions, showing a stronger response to overlapping action plans. Crucially, the connectivity between hippocampus and SMA was modulated by the similarity between the action plans, suggesting their complementary roles in action evaluation. These findings provide evidence for the role of cognitive maps in action selection, challenging classical models of memory taxonomy and its neural bases.

Neuroscience

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand how the brain efficiently selects and evaluates different courses of action and their outcomes. Specifically, the authors explored how the brain forms and utilizes "cognitive maps" to represent the relationships between different actions and outcomes, and how these relationships influence the selection of actions. The research mainly focuses on the roles of the hippocampal - entorhinal cortex system and the motor cortex in this process.

The paper mentions that effective environmental interaction requires weighing and selecting the most appropriate action based on the outcomes of multiple possible actions. However, the specific working mechanisms of these neural mechanisms remain controversial. Through a novel immersive virtual reality experiment, the authors let participants learn two - dimensional abstract movement action - outcome associations and compared different action combinations under the monitoring of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI). The research findings are as follows:

1. **Six - way modulation in the entorhinal cortex**: When participants compared different action plans, the activity in the entorhinal cortex showed six - way modulation, indicating that this area may be involved in the construction of cognitive maps in the abstract action - outcome space.
2. **Relationship between hippocampal activity and outcome similarity**: The intensity of hippocampal activity is proportional to the outcome similarity of different action plans, indicating that the hippocampus plays a crucial role in evaluating the similarity of action outcomes.
3. **Individual action representation in the supplementary motor area (SMA)**: The SMA shows a stronger response to overlapping action plans, indicating the importance of the SMA in representing individual actions.
4. **Connection between the hippocampus and SMA**: The strength of the connection between the hippocampus and SMA is affected by the similarity of action plans, which further supports the complementary roles of these two regions in action evaluation.

These findings challenge the traditional memory classification models and their neural bases and provide evidence for the role of cognitive maps in action selection.