Apparent Diffusion Coefficient fMRI shines a new light on white matter resting-state connectivity, as compared to BOLD
Ines de Riedmatten,Arthur Spencer,Wiktor Olszowy,Ileana O Jelescu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.03.601842
2024-07-05
Abstract:Resting-state functional MRI (rs-fMRI) detects spontaneous low-frequency oscillations in the MRI signal at rest. When they occur simultaneously in distant brain regions, they define functional connectivity (FC) between these regions. While blood oxygen level-dependent (BOLD) fMRI serves as the most widely used contrast for rs-fMRI, its reliance on neurovascular coupling poses challenges in accurately reflecting neuronal activity, resulting in limited spatial and temporal specificity and reduced sensitivity in white matter regions. To overcome these limitations, apparent diffusion coefficient fMRI (ADC-fMRI) is emerging as a promising alternative. This approach captures neuronal activity by monitoring changes in ADC resulting from activity-driven neuromorphological alterations such as transient cell swelling. Using graph theory analysis of resting-state FC networks, this study confirms that ADC-fMRI mirrors the positive correlations observed in BOLD-fMRI in the gray-to-gray matter edges (GM-GM), while diverging significantly from BOLD-fMRI for white-to-white matter (WM-WM) connections. While comparable average clustering and average node strength were found for GM-GM connections, higher average clustering (p < 10-3) and average node strength (p < 10-3) for ADC-fMRI in WM-WM edges suggests that it captures different information to BOLD in the WM. In addition, a significantly higher FC similarity between subjects for ADC-fMRI (mean 0.70, 95% CI [0.68, 0.72]) than BOLD-fMRI (0.38 [0.31, 0.44]) in WM-WM connections suggests a higher reliability of ADC-fMRI in this brain tissue type, demonstrating its broader applicability across the entire brain and reduced sensitivity to physiological noise. Taken together, these results indicate a higher sensitivity and robustness of ADC-fMRI in the WM, and encourage its use, together with careful mitigation of vascular contributions, to further investigate WM functional connectivity.
Neuroscience
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem Addressed by the Paper
This paper aims to explore the use of the Apparent Diffusion Coefficient (ADC) in resting-state functional MRI (rs-fMRI) as a new contrast method to overcome the limitations of traditional Blood Oxygen Level-Dependent (BOLD) fMRI in detecting functional connectivity (FC) in white matter regions.
Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following issues:
1. **Improving the Sensitivity and Reliability of White Matter Functional Connectivity**:
- BOLD-fMRI, due to its reliance on neurovascular coupling, has limited sensitivity and spatiotemporal specificity in white matter regions, leading to inaccurate detection of white matter functional connectivity.
- ADC-fMRI, by monitoring microstructural changes (such as transient cell swelling) induced by neural activity, may more accurately reflect neural activity in white matter, thereby improving the sensitivity and reliability of detecting white matter functional connectivity.
2. **Validating the Consistency of Functional Connectivity Between ADC-fMRI and BOLD-fMRI in Different Brain Regions**:
- Researchers used graph theory analysis to compare the functional connectivity patterns of ADC-fMRI and BOLD-fMRI in gray matter-gray matter (GM-GM), white matter-white matter (WM-WM), and gray matter-white matter (GM-WM) connections to verify whether ADC-fMRI can provide information similar to BOLD-fMRI, especially in white matter regions.
3. **Evaluating the Consistency of Functional Connectivity Across Individuals Using ADC-fMRI**:
- By calculating the similarity of functional connectivity between different subjects, researchers aim to assess whether ADC-fMRI has higher reproducibility and stability in white matter regions, thereby validating its potential for clinical applications.
### Main Findings
- **Gray Matter-Gray Matter Connectivity**:
- ADC-fMRI and BOLD-fMRI showed similar positive correlation patterns in gray matter-gray matter connectivity, but the average positive correlation strength was higher in BOLD-fMRI.
- BOLD-fMRI also displayed more negative correlation connections, which were significantly weakened in ADC-fMRI.
- **White Matter-White Matter Connectivity**:
- ADC-fMRI exhibited higher average clustering coefficients and node strength in white matter-white matter connectivity, indicating that it captures different information in white matter regions compared to BOLD-fMRI.
- The functional connectivity similarity in white matter-white matter connections was significantly higher in ADC-fMRI than in BOLD-fMRI, suggesting higher reliability and reproducibility in white matter regions.
- **Gray Matter-White Matter Connectivity**:
- In gray matter-white matter connectivity, ADC-fMRI and BOLD-fMRI showed similar positive correlation patterns, but there were differences in certain specific connections.
### Conclusion
Overall, this study demonstrates that ADC-fMRI has higher sensitivity and reliability in detecting functional connectivity in white matter regions, particularly in white matter-white matter connections. This provides new tools and methods for future research and clinical applications, especially in scenarios requiring high-precision detection of white matter functional connectivity.