Ecology not genetics explains correlated trait divergence during speciation

Clarissa de Carvalho,Nicholas Planidin,Romain Villoutreix,Victor Soria-Carrasco,Rudiger Riesch,Jeffrey Feder,Thomas Parchman,Jon Slate,Zachariah Gompert,Patrik Nosil

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.07.02.601691

2024-07-04

Abstract:The formation of new species often involves the correlated divergence of multiple traits and genetic regions. However, the mechanisms by which such trait covariation builds up remain poorly understood. In this context, we consider two non-exclusive hypotheses. First, genetic covariance between traits can cause divergent selection on one trait to promote population divergence in correlated traits (a genetic covariation hypothesis). Second, correlated environmental pressures can generate selection on multiple traits, facilitating the evolution of trait complexes (an environmental covariation hypothesis). Here, we test these hypotheses using cryptic coloration (controlled by an incipient supergene) and chemical traits (i.e., cuticular hydrocarbons, CHCs) involved in desiccation resistance and mate choice in Timema cristinae stick insects. We first demonstrate that population divergence in color-pattern is correlated with divergence in some (but not all) CHC traits. We show that when correlated population divergence does occur, it is unlikely to be explained by genetic covariation because within-population genetic covariance between color-pattern and CHCs traits is weak. In contrast, we find that correlated variation in climate and host plant likely generates selection jointly on color-pattern and some CHC traits. This supports the environmental covariation hypothesis, likely via the effects of two correlated environmental axes selecting on different traits. Finally, we provide evidence that misalignment between natural and sexual selection also contributes to patterns of correlated trait divergence. Our results shed light into transitions between phases of speciation by showing that environmental factors can promote population divergence in trait complexes, even without strong genetic covariance.

Evolutionary Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the mechanisms of correlated trait divergence during speciation. Specifically, the authors explore two non-mutually exclusive hypotheses: the genetic covariation hypothesis and the environmental covariation hypothesis. By studying Timema cristinae (a wingless herbivorous insect distributed in the Santa Ynez Mountains of California, USA), the paper investigates the relationship between its camouflage morph polymorphism and cuticular hydrocarbons (CHCs). - **Genetic Covariation Hypothesis**: Suggests that genetic covariation between traits leads to their correlated divergence. - **Environmental Covariation Hypothesis**: Proposes that different traits are subject to correlated environmental selection pressures, leading to their correlated divergence. The study found that there is correlated divergence between camouflage morphs and certain CHC traits across different populations, but this correlation cannot be explained by genetic covariation, as the genetic covariation between camouflage morphs and CHC traits within populations is weak. Instead, the associated variation in climate and host plants may jointly influence camouflage morphs and some CHC traits, supporting the environmental covariation hypothesis. Additionally, the study found that sexual selection on certain CHC traits (such as pentacosane) may conflict with natural selection, which also affects the pattern of correlated trait divergence. This finding helps to understand the transitional mechanisms at different stages of speciation and emphasizes the important role of environmental factors in promoting the differentiation of complex trait assemblages.

Ecology not genetics explains correlated trait divergence during speciation

Convergent phenotypic evolution of the visual system via different molecular routes: How Neotropical cichlid fishes adapt to novel light environments

Divergent dynamics of sexual and habitat isolation at the transition between stick insect populations and species

Time spent together and time spent apart affect song, feather colour and range overlap in tinkerbirds

Color patterns of closely related bird species are more divergent at intermediate levels of breeding-range sympatry

Molecular mechanisms of convergent color pattern evolution

Chromosomal rearrangements preserve adaptive divergence in ecological speciation

The role of mate competition in speciation and divergence: a systematic review

Animal personality adds complexity to the processes of adaptive divergence and speciation

Selection of p53 pathway in adaptive evolution and reproductive isolation in incipient sympatric speciation of Drosophila at Evolution Canyon

The evolution of multiple colour mechanisms is correlated with diversification in sunbirds (Nectariniidae)

Testing the role of ecological selection on colour pattern variation in the butterfly Parnassius clodius

Correlated evolution of conspicuous colouration and burrowing in crayfish

Untangling the contribution of adaptive versus non-adaptive processes in the evolution of reproductive isolation between Coenonympha butterflies.

Divergence of chemosensing during the early stages of speciation

Ecological disruptive selection acting on quantitative loci can drive sympatric speciation

What Predicts Gene Flow During Speciation? The Relative Roles of Time, Space, Morphology and Climate

Divergent warning patterns contribute to assortative mating between incipient Heliconius species

Demography-Dispersal Trait Correlations Modify the Eco-Evolutionary Dynamics of Range Expansion

Color polymorphic carnivores have faster speciation rates

Genomic islands of speciation harbor genes underlying coloration differences in a pair of Neotropical seedeaters