The resilient brain against childhood poverty

Bowen Hu,Tongxi Yang,Yuanyuan Hu,Shaozheng Qin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.06.18.24308965
2024-06-19
Abstract:Poverty remains a persistent structural issue in society, profoundly impacting children's mental health and resilience. However, the influence of poverty on children's resilience and its neural underpinnings is not well understood. This study investigates this impact using a nationally representative sample (N = 11878) and neuroimaging techniques to explore the heterogeneity of resilience mechanisms in poor children. Our findings reveal that poor children (living below the federal poverty threshold) experience exacerbated effects of early life adversities (ELAs) on behavioral problems, which persist into adolescence, indicating disrupted resilience. By subtyping poor children based on neural representations of self-regulation (brain activation during stop signal task), we identified two distinct subtypes: subtype-1, with heightened neural activation, exhibited significantly worse resilience; while subtype-2, with reduced activation, showed resilience levels comparable to non-poor children. Two subtypes did not differ significantly in superficial characteristics including ELA exposure and demographics. However, poor children with subtype-1 had thicker left-middle-frontal-gyrus (L-MFG) brain regions, correlating with fewer behavioral problems and weaker ELA impacts, suggesting a unique resilience mechanism. This L-MFG-based resilience mechanism is exclusive to subtype-1, and not observed in subtype-2 or non-poor children. These findings underscore the importance of understanding individual heterogeneity in resilience mechanisms among disadvantaged children. Our study emphasizes the need for future research to delve deeper into adaptation processes to ELAs and poverty, advocating for the exploration of varied resilience mechanisms to mitigate the stigma associated with poverty and guide interventions aimed at narrowing mental health gradient.
Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to explore the impact of childhood poverty on children's psychological resilience and its neural basis. Specifically, using a nationally representative sample (N = 11,878) and neuroimaging techniques, the researchers explored the heterogeneity of resilience mechanisms in poor children when facing Early Life Adversities (ELAs). ### Main research questions 1. **The impact of poverty on children's psychological resilience**: - By analyzing the behavioral problems of poor children, the researchers hope to explore how poverty affects children's psychological resilience. In particular, when facing early life adversities, are poor children more likely to have behavioral problems, and will these effects last until adolescence? 2. **Heterogeneity of neural representations in poor children**: - By analyzing the brain activation patterns of poor children in the stop - signal task, the researchers attempt to identify different types of poor children. These different types may show different characteristics in neural representations, resulting in different resilience levels. 3. **The relationship between specific brain regions and resilience mechanisms**: - The researchers pay special attention to the relationship between the thickness of the Left Middle Frontal Gyrus (L - MFG) and resilience. They found that in some poor children, the L - MFG area is thicker, which is associated with fewer behavioral problems and a weaker ELA impact, indicating a unique resilience mechanism. ### Research methods - **Sample**: The study used data from 11,878 9 - to 10 - year - old children from 22 sites in the United States. These data were from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development (ABCD) study. - **Measurement tools**: Including neuroimaging data, self - reported demographic data, Early Life Adversities (ELAs) data, and behavioral problems data. - **Neuroimaging analysis**: Using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data and structural magnetic resonance imaging (sMRI) data of the stop - signal task to analyze brain activation patterns and cortical thickness. - **Statistical analysis**: A linear mixed - effects model was used to evaluate the resilience differences between different groups, and the effects of factors such as age, gender, race/ethnicity, and family income were controlled. ### Conclusions The research results reveal significant heterogeneity in the resilience mechanisms of poor children when facing early life adversities. Through the sub - typing of neural representations, the researchers found two different subtypes of poor children. One subtype shows higher neural activation and poorer resilience, while the other subtype shows lower neural activation and a resilience level comparable to that of non - poor children. In addition, there is a significant association between the thickness of the Left Middle Frontal Gyrus (L - MFG) and resilience, which provides a new perspective for understanding the resilience mechanisms of poor children. ### Significance This study emphasizes the importance of understanding the heterogeneity of individuals in resilience mechanisms, providing a theoretical basis for future research and intervention measures aimed at reducing the impact of poverty on children's mental health.