Do the effects of interventions aimed at the prevention of childhood obesity reduce inequities? A re-analysis of randomized trial data from two Cochrane reviews

Jennifer C Palmer,Annabel L Davies,Francesca Spiga,Berit L Heitmann,Russ Jago,Carolyn D Summerbell,Julian PT Higgins
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.06.10.24308372
2024-06-10
Abstract:Public health attempts to prevent obesity in children and young people should aim to minimize health inequalities. We aimed to assess whether there were differences in the effectiveness of the interventions included in two Cochrane reviews according to the eight PROGRESS inequity factors. We collected data on change in BMI (standardized or unstandardized), subgrouped by baseline measures of PROGRESS factors, for intervention and control groups, from trial authors. We calculated the intervention effect per subgroup (mean difference), then contrasted these to estimate interactions between intervention and the baseline factors. We combined interaction estimates for each factor across trials using standard procedures for meta-analysis. Our analysis of interventions from 81 trials found no substantial differences in effectiveness for different subgroups in most scenarios. However, in the younger age group (5-11 years), the effect of interventions on standardized BMI appeared to be higher in boys. The Cochrane reviews found that interventions promoting physical activity (only) have a beneficial effect on BMI (compared with a control group) for children and young people aged 5-18 years, as well as interventions promoting physical activity alongside healthy eating for 5-11 year olds. Although these beneficial effects were small, when delivered at scale, they may have the potential to contribute meaningfully to reducing the prevalence of childhood obesity. Our findings suggest that those responsible for public health can promote these beneficial interventions without major concerns about increasing inequalities. Because many of the interventions studied, including school-based interventions, provide building blocks of , the findings are relevant to policy and practice. National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR).
What problem does this paper attempt to address?