Residual immunity and seasonality of an epidemic

Siyu Chen,David Sankoff
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.31.24308217
2024-08-12
Abstract:We present a dynamical model of the onset and severity of cyclical epidemic disease taking account only of seasonal boosts of antibody during the infectious season and residual immunity remaining from one season to the next. We also compile data from public health sources on the annual number of cases of influenza A and peak infectivity month over a quarter century. In these data, we discover that there is a negative correlation between the change in number of cases from one year to the next and the shift of peak infectivity month between the two seasons, although this does not extend to a prediction of epidemic timing or case number based on the the previous season's statistics. Simulating the mathematical model, we discover that there is also a negative correlation between the change in titer from one season to the next and the shift of peak infectivity month between the two seasons, suggesting that the empirical results can be explained by our minimal boost-and-wane model. In addition, the model predicts that suppressing the epidemic for one season, or witnessing a strong surge for one season, both have lasting effects for a number of successive seasons.
Epidemiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores a dynamic model of a seasonal infectious disease (using Influenza A as an example) with the aim of understanding how the onset time and severity of seasonal infectious diseases are influenced by the previous season. Specifically, the study attempts to answer the following key questions: 1. **The role of seasonal boosting and residual immunity**: By constructing a simplified mathematical model to describe the increase in antibody levels during the infection season and their gradual decline during the non-infection season (i.e., the "boosting-decay" process), the study investigates how these processes affect the periodic behavior of seasonal infectious diseases. 2. **Statistical data analysis**: The study analyzes statistical data of Influenza A from the past 25 years, exploring the relationship between changes in case numbers and peak time variations across different seasons, and evaluates whether these changes can predict the epidemic situation of the next season. 3. **Model validation**: Simulation results show that there is indeed a negative correlation between changes in case numbers and peak time variations in the model, which is consistent with observations in actual data, indicating that the model can reasonably explain this phenomenon. 4. **Long-term impact**: The study also explores the impact of suppressing an epidemic in one season (e.g., through non-pharmaceutical interventions) or experiencing an exceptionally severe season on subsequent seasons. Experiments indicate that this impact lasts for several years rather than disappearing immediately. In summary, the core of this paper lies in proposing a new modeling approach to understand and predict the behavior of seasonal infectious diseases, particularly focusing on how the simple "boosting-decay" mechanism can explain the inter-seasonal correlation and its impact on long-term trends.