Intersex/Differences of Sex Development (I/DSD) Traits: Exploring Their Association with 15% of Phenotypically Detailed Genetic Disorders

Leah Ragno,Louise C. Pyle
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.27.24307983
2024-05-27
Abstract:The study of Intersex traits or Differences of Sex Development (I/DSD) is an imperative area within medical genetics that confronts a long-standing problem: the prevalence of these conditions in the population is not fully clear, likely undercounted, and therefore no universally agreed upon numbers exist. Proportions among rare differences are not fully understood. While each specific I/DSD condition is individually rare, together they are estimated to affect about 0.7-1.7% of people worldwide (Fausto‐Sterling, 1993). Over 10% of individuals with I/DSD traits exhibit comorbidities affecting other bodily systems, suggesting a broader, systemic impact of these conditions. The comprehensive phenotypic spectrum and systemic implications of I/DSD traits are not well-documented, likely due to social, cultural, and privacy concerns that may contribute to the under-phenotyping of genital variations. This research aims to delineate the disease landscape associated with I/DSD traits. By using the Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man (OMIM) database, a comprehensive resource for human genes and genetic disorders, we compiled an expert list of 155 Human Phenotype Ontology (HPO) terms that encompass the entirety of the medically defined I/DSD space. These terms were cross-referenced with the OMIM database to pinpoint diseases annotated with these HPO terms. Out of 8,181 phenotypically detailed diseases listed in OMIM and included in the HPO database, we discovered that 1,264 (15.5%) have associations with I/DSD-related HPO terms, signifying their presence in I/DSD traits. This substantial overlap underscores the need to rethink I/DSD not just as isolated anomalies but as a continuum of conditions that are crucial for a broader understanding of health issues. It also highlights that I/DSD traits are relatively common within the realm of rare differences, emphasizing the necessity for specialists, such as clinical geneticists, to be well-versed in I/DSD. Our findings call for a shift in the medical community's perception and approach to studying I/DSD traits. Further research is required to confirm these associations and to explore the relationship between I/DSD traits and overall health.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Aims to Address This paper aims to explore the association between intersex traits or differences in sex development (I/DSD) and genetic diseases. Specifically, the researchers hope to address existing issues through the following aspects: 1. **Clarify the prevalence of I/DSD**: Although the actual prevalence of I/DSD in the population is unclear and may be underestimated, it is estimated that about 0.7-1.7% of the global population is affected. The researchers hope to better understand the prevalence of these conditions through detailed data analysis. 2. **Systemic impact**: More than 10% of I/DSD patients exhibit complications affecting other body systems, indicating that these conditions are not merely isolated anomalies but part of broader genetic diseases. The researchers aim to reveal the systemic impact of I/DSD to provide insights into more comprehensive health issues. 3. **Redefine I/DSD**: By using the Online Mendelian Inheritance in Man (OMIM) database and the Human Phenotype Ontology (HPO), the researchers compiled an expert list of 155 HPO terms covering all medically defined I/DSD. The study found that 15.5% of OMIM diseases have HPO terms related to I/DSD, suggesting a need to rethink I/DSD as a continuous spectrum rather than a series of isolated anomalies. 4. **Increase awareness among healthcare professionals**: The findings emphasize the need for clinical geneticists and other healthcare professionals to be more familiar with the diverse manifestations of I/DSD to ensure accurate diagnosis and effective management. ### Main Findings - **15.5% of OMIM diseases**: Out of 8,181 detailed OMIM diseases, 1,264 (15.5%) are associated with HPO terms related to I/DSD. - **Systemic impact**: I/DSD affects not only the reproductive system but also multiple organ systems, including the nervous system and endocrine system. - **Genetic patterns**: Certain genetic patterns (such as X-linked recessive inheritance, autosomal recessive inheritance, etc.) are more common in I/DSD-related diseases. - **Phenotypic classification**: The distribution of I/DSD-related diseases in primary and secondary phenotypic categories is significantly different from other OMIM diseases, particularly in the reproductive system, head and neck, and endocrine system. ### Conclusion The findings highlight the complexity and diversity of I/DSD and its impact on multiple body systems. This not only helps to better understand I/DSD but also provides important references for clinical diagnosis and management. Future research should further confirm these associations and explore the relationship between I/DSD traits and overall health.