Application of RNA-sequencing based predictive model for endometrial WOI in patients with recurrent implantation failure: a prospective cohort study
aihua he,Tianli Yang,Sijia Lu,Yangyun Zou,Cheng Wan,Jing Zhao,Nenghui Liu,Donge Liu,Yumei Li,Yonggang Wang,Bin Xu,Jie Hao,Shi Xie,Jing Fu,Hui Li,Hong Wu,Qiong Zhang,Yanping Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.26.24307954
2024-05-27
Abstract:Abstract:
Background: Accurate prediction for endometrial window of implantation (WOI) would maximize the effectiveness of assisted reproductive technology. Previously, we have established a predictive model for endometrial WOI (rsERT) by three-time points sampling from the same patient at 48-hour intervals during one menstrual cycle. However, it is imperative to build a modified rsERT by single time point sampling in order to prevent multiple sampling and collateral harm.
Methods: A two-phase study was conducted. In the first phase, patients with successful clinical pregnancy after personalized embryo transfer (pET) guided by three-time points rsERT were recruited. Endometrial tissues obtained from single time point were used for the modified rsERT establishment. In the second phase, recurrent implantation failure (RIF) patients were recruited and assigned to experimental group underwent pET guided by modified rsERT or control group underwent conventional ET. Pregnant outcomes were recorded and analyzed.
Results: The modified rsERT was established using 91 eligible participants and could provide hour-based predictive result of endometrial WOI with an average accuracy of 94.51% with sensitivity and specificity being 92.73% and 96.27% using 10-fold CV. 176 RIF patients were recruited in the second phase (experimental group: n=88; control group: n=88). 40 of 88 (45.45%) patients showed WOI displacement, and 5.00% (2/40) of them were with advanced WOI, and the remaining 95.00% (38/40) with delayed WOI. The β-hCG positive rate, intrauterine pregnancy rate (IPR) and implantation rate (IR) of the experimental group were significantly improved (β-hCG positive rate: 67.05% vs. 39.77%, P=0.000; IPR: 61.36% vs. 31.82%, P=0.000; IR: 42.86% vs. 24.66%, P=0.001). While, pregnancy outcomes were not significantly different using different endometrial preparation protocols (β-hCG positive rate: 42.86% vs. 35.90%, P=0.508; IPR: 38.78% vs. 23.08%, P=0.116; IR: 30.12% vs. 17.46%, P=0.085).
Conclusions: The modified rsERT allowed WOI prediction using a single time point endometrial biopsy and pregnancy outcomes were significantly improved. This could provide an enhanced endometrial receptivity test as an alternative, requiring only a single time point sampling for RIF patients.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper mainly discusses how to improve a prediction model based on RNA sequencing to determine the window of implantation (WOI) in the endometrium, in order to improve the success rate of assisted reproductive technology (ART), especially for patients with repeated implantation failure (RIF). The study was conducted in two phases. Firstly, by optimizing the previous prediction model, a new method that can predict WOI with a single sample was established, and its accuracy was validated in the first phase by comparing data from successfully pregnant patients. Then, in the second phase, this improved model was applied to RIF patients. Compared with conventional embryo transfer (ET), the results showed that personalized embryo transfer (pET) guided by the improved model significantly improved the pregnancy success rate, intrauterine pregnancy rate, and implantation rate.
The paper points out that the human endometrium undergoes a series of changes after ovulation, forming a brief window of implantation. Accurately predicting this window is crucial for successful pregnancy. However, existing technologies cannot reliably determine whether the endometrium is in a synchronous state during embryo transfer. The researchers identified gene expression patterns related to endometrial receptivity through RNA sequencing and developed a new prediction model that can predict WOI in hours, reducing the invasiveness and number of samples required for patients, thereby improving the treatment effectiveness for RIF patients.