Abstract:Uncertainty permeates decisions from the trivial to the profound. Integrating brain and behavioral evidence, we discuss how probabilistic (varied outcomes) and temporal (delayed outcomes) uncertainty differ across age and individuals; how critical tests adjudicate between theories of uncertainty (prospect theory and fuzzy-trace theory); and how these mechanisms might be represented in the brain. The same categorical gist representations of gains and losses account for choices and eye-tracking data in both value-allocation (add money to gambles) and risky-choice tasks, disconfirming prospect theory and confirming predictions of fuzzy-trace theory. The analysis is extended to delay discounting and disambiguated choices, explaining hidden-zero effects that similarly turn on categorical distinctions between some gain and no gain, certain gain and uncertain gain, gain and loss, and now and later. Bold activation implicates dorsolateral prefrontal and posterior parietal cortices in gist strategies that are not just one tool in a grab-bag of cognitive options but rather are general strategies that systematically predict behaviors across many different tasks involving probabilistic and temporal uncertainty. High valuation (e.g., ventral striatum; ventromedial prefrontal cortex) and low executive control (e.g., lateral prefrontal cortex) contribute to risky and impatient choices, especially in youth. However, valuation in ventral striatum supports reward-maximizing and gist strategies in adulthood. Indeed, processing becomes less "rational" in the sense of maximizing gains and more noncompensatory (eye movements indicate fewer tradeoffs) as development progresses from adolescence to adulthood, as predicted. Implications for theoretically predicted "public-health paradoxes" are discussed, including gist versus verbatim thinking in drug experimentation and addiction.

Multifaceted confidence in exploratory choice

Confidence Is the Bridge between Multi-stage Decisions

Multiple and subject-specific roles of uncertainty in reward-guided decision-making

Humans adaptively resolve the explore-exploit dilemma under cognitive constraints: Evidence from a multi-armed bandit task

Choice confidence bridges credit assignment to levels of decision hierarchy

Uncertainty avoidance versus conditioned reinforcement: exploring paradoxical choice in rats

Choice, Difficulty, and Confidence in the Brain.

To Believe or Not to Believe: Trust Choice Modulates Brain Responses in Outcome Evaluation

Rationality and Psychological Accuracy of Risky Choice Models Based on Option- vs. Dimension-Wise Evaluations

Learning and choosing in an uncertain world: An investigation of the explore-exploit dilemma in static and dynamic environments

Enjoying the present or saving for the future: the influence of luck perception on intertemporal choice

Neural basis of concurrent deliberation toward a choice and degree of confidence

Are decisions under risk malleable?

Quantitative vs. Qualitative Outcomes: A Longitudinal Study of Risk and Ambiguity in Monetary and Medical Decision-Making

Confidence control for efficient behaviour in dynamic environments

Good fortune but bad luck? Predictable versus unpredictable gains and losses in risky choice

Distinct computational mechanisms of uncertainty processing explain opposing exploratory behaviors in anxiety and apathy

Confidence in Decision-Making During Probabilistic Tactile Learning Related to Distinct Thalamo-Prefrontal Pathways.

Contradictory deviations from maximization: Environment-specific biases, or reflections of basic properties of human learning?

Novelty and uncertainty differentially drive exploration across development

Critical tests of fuzzy trace theory in brain and behavior: uncertainty across time, probability, and development