Preterm Birth Phenotyping Based on Cervical Length and Immune-Mediated Factors
Paolo Ivo Cavoretto,Massimo Candiani,Antonio Farina
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.4559
2024-04-12
JAMA Network Open
Abstract:Cervical length (CL) screening by ultrasonographic measurement is an established tool widely implemented in the clinical protocols of preterm birth (PTB) prediction and prevention. Growing evidence has shown immune-mediated factors in the etiology of spontaneous PTB (sPTB), with robust biological plausibility supporting deep interrelationships with progressive cervical shortening. We explore a retrospective cohort study that examined the sequential measurement of CL and leucocyte markers in both singleton and twin pregnancies. 1 The study's objective was to identify the clinical presentations associated with sPTB in relation to variations in these parameters. 1 Progressive CL shortening was associated with higher rates of sPTB in both singletons (4.1% vs 2.7%) and twins (41.9% vs 18.2%) as compared with cases with stable CL. In addition, in singleton pregnancies, individuals in the early preterm birth subgroup with a shortened or stable CL had elevated total white blood cell count, neutrophil count, and neutrophil-to-lymphocyte ratio, along with a reduced lymphocyte-to-monocyte ratio, in comparison with individuals in the full-term birth subgroup. However, in twins, similar changes were exclusive to those with a shortened cervix. Finally, the study quantified the association between immune-related indicators and risk of sPTB, incorporating CL. In singleton pregnancies, an increase in the white blood cell count and neutrophil count was associated with early sPTB for both stable and shortened CL. Conversely, in twins, there was a significantly higher white blood cell count, neutrophil count, and monocyte count only in the subgroup with shortened CL. This study 1 offers an interesting and original perspective, proposing a novel combined method for approaching the characterization and investigation of sPTB by looking at different clinical presentations of patients: those with or without cervical shortening and those with or without signs of systemic inflammation. This study found 2 distinct potential mechanisms of sPTB for twins and singletons. In singleton pregnancies, maternal immune response was found to be associated with sPTB irrespective of whether the woman had a shortened or stable CL. However, for twin pregnancies, maternal immune response was only associated with sPTB in women with a shortened CL and not in those with a stable cervix. On this basis, the authors concluded that the mechanism of sPTB may be different in singletons and twins; in twin pregnancy with stable CL, sPTB appears to be unassociated with immunological factors. The major merit of the study 1 is to attempt to move toward a better assessment of the risk of sPTB by including multiple clinically relevant markers encompassing simple established measurements of anatomy (ie, CL) and novel indicators of pathophysiology (ie, markers of inflammation). In addition, the work responds, albeit partially, to the need to generate new predictive multiparametric models for sPTB, relying not on a single univariate (and static) cutoff of CL and its percentile for gestational age but on longitudinal measures of the same, introducing a more relevant analysis design for the clinical and anatomical natural history of sPTB. The major limitations are related to lack of information on medications, including progesterone, tocolytics antibiotics, and steroids; lack of assessment of any infectious etiology; and exclusion of severe preterm birth before 28 weeks' gestation. The article does not provide an explanation for the identification of distinct mechanisms underlying sPTB in singleton pregnancies compared with twin pregnancies, especially regarding why immune factors seem to be associated with sPTB exclusively in twin pregnancies with a shortened CL. Retrospective studies may involve risk of selection bias since it is more common to perform longitudinal measurements in higher-risk cases. However, the authors correctly discussed most of these limitations, which were partly due to the regulation and current practice accepted in China, and stated that longitudinal CL is performed routinely at their center. Extensive research on PTB phenotypes indicates a move away from solely relying on gestational age thresholds for defining PTB. 2 ,3 Instead, there is a push to incorporate factors such as clinical presentation, features, and the type of PTB initiation to pursue a deeper understanding of PTB etiology. This recommendation stems from the recognition that these aspects significantly influence infant outcomes for up to 2 years of age, with different extents in different PTB phenotypes, at fixed gestational ages. 3 In twin pregnancies, representing a clearly separate phenotype, uterine distension plays a central role in the pathophysiology of cervical shortening, which in fact appears here 1 unrelated to immune factors. Conversely, in s -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal