Comprehensive network modeling approaches unravel dynamic enhancer-promoter interactions across neural differentiation

William DeGroat,Fumitaka Inoue,Tal Ashuach,Nir Yosef,Nadav Ahituv,Anat Kreimer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.22.595375
2024-05-23
Abstract:Increasing evidence suggests that a substantial proportion of disease-associated mutations occur in enhancers, regions of non-coding DNA essential to gene regulation. Understanding the structures and mechanisms of regulatory programs this variation affects can shed light on the apparatuses of human diseases. We collected epigenetic and gene expression datasets from seven early time points during neural differentiation. Focusing on this model system, we constructed networks of enhancer-promoter interactions, each at an individual stage of neural induction. These networks served as the base for a rich series of analyses, through which we demonstrated their temporal dynamics and enrichment for various disease-associated variants. We applied the Girvan-Newman clustering algorithm to these networks to reveal biologically relevant substructures of regulation. Additionally, we demonstrated methods to validate predicted enhancer-promoter interactions using transcription factor overexpression and massively parallel reporter assays. Our findings suggest a generalizable framework for exploring gene regulatory programs and their dynamics across developmental processes. This includes a comprehensive approach to studying the effects of disease-associated variation on transcriptional networks. The techniques applied to our networks have been published alongside our findings as a computational tool, E-P-INAnalyzer. Our procedure can be utilized across different cellular contexts and disorders.
Genomics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problems does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to solve the following key problems: 1. **Understanding the dynamic changes in enhancer - promoter interactions**: - Researchers hope to reveal how the interactions between enhancers and promoters change over time during neural differentiation. These interactions are important components of the gene regulatory network and are crucial for understanding cell fate determination and developmental processes. 2. **Identifying the impact of disease - related genetic variations on the transcriptional network**: - The paper explores how to map disease - related variations into the enhancer - promoter interaction network to understand how these variations affect gene expression and regulation. Specifically, the researchers focused on variations related to neurodevelopmental disorders and mental illnesses (such as autism, schizophrenia, etc.). 3. **Developing and validating methods for predicting enhancer - promoter interactions**: - Researchers used multiple omics datasets (such as ATAC - seq, ChIP - seq, RNA - seq, etc.) to construct enhancer - promoter interaction networks at different time points and validated these predictions through experimental methods (such as transcription factor overexpression and massively parallel reporter gene analysis). 4. **Exploring the modular structure of gene regulatory programs**: - By applying the Girvan - Newman clustering algorithm, the researchers revealed biologically relevant sub - structures in the enhancer - promoter interaction network, thus better understanding the patterns and mechanisms of gene regulation. 5. **Providing a general framework for studying gene regulatory networks**: - The researchers developed a computational tool, E - P - IN Analyzer, for constructing and analyzing enhancer - promoter interaction networks. This tool can help other researchers conduct similar studies in their model systems of interest. ### Summary of the abstract content This paper constructed enhancer - promoter interaction networks (E - P - INs) at different time points during neural differentiation by integrating multiple omics datasets. The study revealed the dynamic changes of these networks and found an enrichment of variations related to neural development and mental diseases. In addition, the researchers revealed regulatory sub - structures through clustering analysis and validated the predicted enhancer - promoter interactions through experimental methods. Finally, they developed a computational tool named E - P - IN Analyzer, providing a general framework for studying gene regulatory networks. ### Examples of formulas Some of the formulas involved in the paper include: - **Jaccard similarity**: Used to compare the overlap between two sets. \[ J(A, B)=\frac{|A\cap B|}{|A\cup B|} \] where \(A\) and \(B\) are two sets, \(|A\cap B|\) represents the number of elements in the intersection, and \(|A\cup B|\) represents the number of elements in the union. - **Fisher's Exact Test**: Used to evaluate the association between enhancers and differentially expressed genes. \[ P(X\geq x)=\sum_{i = x}^{n_1}\frac{(n_1!)(n_2!)}{(i!)(n_1 - i)!(x - i)!(n_2 - x + i)!} \] where \(n_1\) and \(n_2\) are the sizes of the two samples respectively, and \(x\) is the number of observed events. Through the solutions to these problems, the researchers hope to provide new insights into understanding the gene regulatory mechanisms and their roles in diseases.