Canonical neurodevelopmental trajectories of structural and functional manifolds

Alicja Monaghan,Richard A.I. Bethelehem,Danyal Akarca,Daniel Margulies,the CALM Team,Duncan S Astle
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.20.594657
2024-05-20
Abstract:Organisational gradients refer to a continuous low-dimensional embedding of brain regions and can quantify core organisational principles of complex systems like the human brain. Mapping how these organisational principles are altered or refined across development and phenotypes is essential to understanding the relationship between brain and behaviour. Taking a developmental approach and leveraging longitudinal and cross-sectional data from two multi-modal neuroimaging datasets, spanning the full neurotypical-neurodivergent continuum, we charted the organisational variability of structural (N = 887) and functional (N = 728) gradients, across childhood and adolescence (6-19 years old). Across datasets, despite differing phenotypes, we observe highly similar structural and functional gradients. These gradients, or organisational principles, are highly stable across development, with the exact same ordering across early childhood into mid-adolescence. However, there is substantial developmental change in the strength of embedding within those gradients: by modelling developmental trajectories as non-linear splines, we show that structural and functional gradients exhibit sensitive periods and are refined across development. Specifically, structural gradients gradually contract in low-dimensional space as networks become more integrated, whilst the functional manifold expands, indexing functional specialisation. The coupling of these structural and functional gradients follows a unimodal-association axis and varies across individuals, with developmental effects concentrated in the more plastic higher-order networks. Importantly, these developmental effects on coupling, in these higher-order networks, are attenuated in the neurodivergent sample. Finally, we mapped structure-function coupling onto dimensions of psychopathology and cognition and demonstrate that coupling is a robust predictor of dimensions of cognition, such as working memory, but not psychopathology. In summary, across clinical and community samples, we demonstrate consistent principles of structural and functional brain organisation, with progressive structural integration and functional segregation. These are gradients are established early in life, refined through development, and their coupling is a robust predictor of working memory.
Neuroscience
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the problem of understanding how the fundamental principles of human brain structure and functional organization develop during childhood and adolescence, and how these principles vary with individual cognitive and behavioral differences. Specifically, the researchers used longitudinal and cross-sectional multimodal neuroimaging data to explore the variability and developmental trajectories of brain structure and functional gradients in children and adolescents aged 6 to 19 years. ### Main Questions: 1. **What are the fundamental principles of brain organization?** - The researchers aim to reveal low-dimensional embedding patterns of brain structure and functional organization, which can quantify the core organizational principles of complex systems like the human brain. 2. **When are these principles established?** - By analyzing data from different age groups, the researchers hope to determine when and how these organizational principles are established. 3. **How do these principles change with individual cognitive and behavioral differences?** - The researchers attempt to link changes in brain structure and functional organization to individual cognitive and psychopathological dimensions to understand the impact of these changes on cognitive abilities (such as working memory) and psychopathology. ### Specific Research Objectives: - **Mapping the developmental trajectories of structural and functional gradients**: By analyzing structural and functional gradients in two multimodal neuroimaging datasets, the researchers aim to map the developmental trajectories of these gradients during childhood and adolescence. - **Exploring individual variability and sensitive periods**: The researchers use non-linear splines to explore sensitive periods and refinement processes of structural and functional gradients during development. - **Analyzing structure-function coupling**: The researchers also investigate the coupling relationship between structural and functional gradients and map it to cognitive and psychopathological dimensions to understand the impact of these couplings on cognition and behavior. ### Methods: - **Data Sources**: The researchers used two large multimodal neuroimaging datasets, one from a community sample in Rockland County, USA (NKI Rockland Sample), and the other from a clinical and educational service sample in Cambridge, UK (CALM). - **Data Analysis**: The researchers used Diffusion Map Embedding (DME) techniques to extract gradients from structural and functional connectomes and analyzed the developmental trajectories and individual variability of these gradients using statistical methods such as Generalized Additive Mixed Models (GAMMs). ### Results: - **High stability of structural and functional gradients**: The study found that structural and functional gradients are highly stable during the development of children and adolescents, although significant developmental changes exist in certain networks. - **Contraction of structural gradients and expansion of functional gradients**: Structural gradients gradually contract in low-dimensional space, indicating that networks become more integrated, while functional gradients gradually expand, indicating functional specialization. - **Development of structure-function coupling**: Structure-function coupling shows significant developmental effects in higher-order networks, which are attenuated in neurodiverse samples. - **Cognitive prediction**: Structure-function coupling is a robust predictor of cognitive dimensions such as working memory but is unrelated to psychopathology. Overall, the paper reveals the developmental trajectories of the fundamental principles of brain structure and functional organization during childhood and adolescence and their relationship with individual cognitive and behavioral differences through detailed multimodal neuroimaging data analysis.