Leveraging regulatory monitoring data for quantitative microbial risk assessment of Legionella pneumophila in cooling towers

Emile Sylvestre,Dominique Charron,Xavier Lefebvre,Emilie Bedard,Michele Prevost

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.19.24307585

2024-05-20

Abstract:Cooling towers are critical engineered water systems for air conditioning and refrigeration but can create favorable conditions for Legionella pneumophila growth and aerosolization. Human exposure to L. pneumophila-contaminated aerosols can cause Legionnaire's disease. Routine monitoring of L. pneumophila in cooling towers offers possibilities to develop quantitative microbial risk assessment (QMRA) to guide system design, operation, control, and maintenance. Here, we used the regulatory monitoring database from Quebec, Canada, to develop statistical models for predicting L. pneumophila concentration variability in cooling towers and integrate these models into a screening-level QMRA to predict human health risks. Analysis of 105,463 monthly L. pneumophila test results revealed that the exceedance rate of the 10,000 colony forming unit (CFU) per liter threshold was constant at 10% from 2016 to 2020, emphasizing the need to better validate the efficacy of corrective measures following the threshold exceedances. Among 2,852 cooling towers, 51.2% reported no detections, 38.5% had up to nine positives, and 10.2% over ten. The gamma or the lognormal distributions adequately described site-specific variations in L. pneumophila concentrations, but parametric uncertainty was very high for the lognormal distribution. We showed that rigorous model comparison is essential to predict peak concentrations accurately. Using QMRA, we found that, to meet a health-based target of 10-6 DALY/pers.-year for clinical severity infections, an average L. pneumophila concentration below 1.4 x 10,000 CFU L-1 should be maintained in cooling towers. We identified 137 cooling towers at risk of exceeding this limit, primarily due to the observation or prediction of rare peak concentrations above 100,000 CFU L-1. Effective mitigation of those peaks is critical to controlling public health risks associated with L. pneumophila.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses how to quantify the microbial risk assessment of Legionella pneumophila in cooling towers using regulatory monitoring data. The study used the regulatory monitoring database in Quebec, Canada to develop statistical models to predict the variability of Legionella pneumophila concentration in cooling towers, and integrated it into quantitative microbial risk assessment (QMRA) to predict human health risks.

The authors analyzed 105,463 Legionella pneumophila detection results between 2016 and 2020 and found that the frequency of concentrations exceeding the threshold of 104 colony-forming units (CFU) per liter remained at 10%. They emphasized the need to better verify the effectiveness of corrective measures taken after exceeding the threshold. The study found that approximately 51.2% of samples in cooling towers did not detect Legionella pneumophila, 38.5% of samples had 1 to 9 positive results, and 10.2% of the samples exceeded 10 times.

The paper proposes the use of gamma distribution or log-normal distribution to describe the variation of Legionella pneumophila concentration at specific locations, but the uncertainty of the parameters in the log-normal distribution is high. Through QMRA, the study concludes that in order to achieve a target of annual human infection rate of 10-6 DALY based on health, the average Legionella pneumophila concentration in cooling towers should be maintained below 1.4×104 CFU per liter. The study identified 137 cooling towers that may exceed this limit, mainly due to rare peak concentrations exceeding 105 CFU per liter.

The main objectives of the study include developing statistical models to predict the variability and uncertainty of Legionella pneumophila concentration, establishing model comparison and selection frameworks, and incorporating the selected model into the QMRA model to predict human health risks caused by aerosol exposure from cooling towers. Through these methods, the public health risks associated with Legionella pneumophila can be managed and evaluated more effectively.