Understanding Antibody-Target Antigen Interactions and the Avidity Effect Using Mathematical Modelling

Luke Alexander Heirene,Helen Byrne,Eamonn Gaffney,James Yates
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.10.593537
2024-05-14
Abstract:Immunotherapies are designed to exploit the immune system to target pathologies, for instance, but not exclusively, cancer. Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are an important class of immunotherapies that induce anti-tumour effects in numerous ways. Fundamental to the success of mAbs in cancer treatments are their interactions with target antigens. For example, binding multiple antigens, which increases binding affinity, termed the avidity effect, has been shown to impact treatment outcomes. However, there has been limited theoretical analysis addressing the impacts of antibody-antigen interactions on avidity, potency, and efficacy. Hence, our aim is to develop a mathematical model to develop insight on these impacts. We analyse an ordinary differential equation model of bivalent, monospecific IgG antibodies binding to membrane bound antigens. We obtain equilibrium solutions of the model and conduct a global parameter sensitivity analysis to identify which antibody-antigen interactions impact quantities, such as antigen occupancy, that contribute to mAb potency and efficacy. We show that the ratio of antibody to antigen number impacts antigen occupancy, bound antibody number and whether an antibody can bind both its antigen-binding arms. A sensitivity analysis reveals that antigen occupancy and the ratio of bound antibody to total antigen number are sensitive to the antibody-antigen binding rates only for high antibody concentrations. We identify parameter ranges in which the avidity effect is predicted to be large for antigen occupancy and bound antibody numbers. These results could be used in the preclinical development of mAb therapies by predicting conditions which enhance mAb potency, efficacy, and the avidity effect.
Systems Biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to understand the antibody-antigen interaction and the affinity enhancement effect through mathematical modeling, especially in the application of immunotherapy. Immunotherapy utilizes the immune system to fight diseases such as cancer, where monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) are an important treatment modality. The interaction between mAbs and target antigens is crucial for their effectiveness in cancer treatment, including the affinity enhancement effect achieved by binding multiple antigens, which affects the treatment outcome. The paper analyzes a ordinary differential equation model that describes the binding process of bivalent, monospecific IgG antibodies to membrane-bound antigens. Through equilibrium solutions and global parameter sensitivity analysis, the study investigates which antibody-antigen interaction parameters affect key quantities such as antigen occupancy and bound antibody count, which are related to the potency and efficacy of mAbs. The study finds that the ratio of antibody to antigen influences antigen occupancy, the number of bound antibodies, and whether the antibody can simultaneously bind to two antigens. The sensitivity analysis of parameters shows that at high antibody concentrations, the antigen occupancy and the ratio of bound antibodies to the total antigen count affect the binding rate. Furthermore, a parameter range that predicts a significant affinity enhancement effect is determined. The paper suggests that these results are useful for the development of preclinical mAb therapy, as they can predict the conditions for enhancing mAb potency, efficacy, and affinity enhancement effect. However, there is currently no consensus regarding which parameters controlling the antibody-antigen interaction are most important for mAb potency and efficacy. Through mathematical modeling, the paper explores how these factors affect the regulation of antibody-antigen interaction in mAb therapy, such as the binding state, binding rate, antibody concentration, and antigen density.