Optimizing clinical interpretability of functional evidence in epilepsy-related ion channel variants

Shridhar Parthasarathy,Stacey R Cohen,Eryn Fitch,Priya Vaidiswaran,Sarah M Ruggiero,Laina Lusk,Victoria Chisari,David Lewis-Smith,Stephan Lauxmann,Christian M Bosselmann,Christopher H Thompson,Eric R Wengert,Ulrike Hedrich,Shiva Ganesan,Ganna Balagura,Roland Krause,Julie Xian,Peter D Galer,Manuela Pendziwiat,Eduardo Perez-Palma,Mauno Vihinen,Jennifer Hart,Melissa J Landrum,Dennis Lal,Edward C Cooper,Holger Lerche,Ethan M Goldberg,Andreas Brunklaus,Carlos G Vanoye,Stephanie Schorge,Alfred L George Jr.,Ingo Helbig

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.05.09.593343

2024-05-14

Abstract:Variants in genes encoding the voltage-gated ion channels are among the most common monogenic causes of epilepsy and neurodevelopmental disorders. Functional effects of a variant are increasingly important for diagnosis and therapeutic decisions. To incorporate knowledge regarding functional consequences in formal clinical variant interpretation, we developed an approach for evaluating multiple functional measurements within the Bayesian framework of the modified ACMG/AMP guidelines. We analyzed 216 functional assessments of 191 variants in SCN1A (n=74), SCN2A (n=66), SCN3A (n=18), and SCN8A (n=33). Of 20 commonly measured biophysical parameters, the most frequent drivers of overall functional consequence were persistent current (f=0.54), voltage dependence of activation (f=0.51), and voltage dependence of fast inactivation (f=0.40) for gain-of-function and peak current (f=0.87) for loss-of-function. By comparing measurements of 23 benign variants, we determined thresholds by which published data on these four parameters confer Strong evidence of variant pathogenicity (likelihood ratio > 18.7) under the ACMG/AMP rubric. Similarly, we delineated evidence weights for the most common epilepsy-related potassium channel gene, KCNQ2, through reports of 80 pathogenic and 24 benign variants, accounting for heterozygous and homozygous experimental conditions. We collected the resulting categorization of functional data into FENICS, a biomedical ontology of 152 standardized terms for coherent annotation of electrophysiological results. Across 271 variants in SCN1A/2A/3A/8A and KCNQ2, 1,731 annotations are available in ClinVar, facilitating use of this evidence in variant classification. In summary, we introduce and apply an ACMG/AMP-calibrated framework for electrophysiological studies in epilepsy-related channelopathies to delineate the impact of functional evidence on clinical variant interpretation.

Genetics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects:

1. **Clinical interpretation of standardized electrophysiological experimental results**: The paper aims to develop a method to evaluate multiple functional measurements through the improved ACMG/AMP guidelines in the Bayesian framework, thereby optimizing the clinical interpretation of the functional evidence of ion channel variants related to epilepsy. This helps improve clinicians' understanding of these variants and the accuracy of diagnosis.

2. **Determination of the thresholds of functional evidence**: The authors analyzed 191 variants out of 216 functional evaluations, involving the SCN1A, SCN2A, SCN3A, and SCN8A genes. Through the measurement of 23 benign variants, the thresholds of four key parameters (persistent current, activation voltage - dependence, fast inactivation voltage - dependence, and peak current) were determined, and these thresholds can provide strong evidence to support the pathogenicity of variants (likelihood ratio > 18.7).

3. **Extension to the potassium channel gene KCNQ2**: The paper also explored how to apply this framework to the most common epilepsy - related potassium channel gene KCNQ2, and established the evidence weights under different experimental conditions through the reports of 80 pathogenic and 24 benign variants.

4. **Construction of the FENICS ontology**: In order to standardize the description of electrophysiological experimental results, the authors developed a biomedical ontology named FENICS (Functional Electrophysiology Nomenclature for Ion Channels), which contains 152 standardized terms for consistently annotating electrophysiological results. This helps to use these data more accurately in clinical practice for variant classification.

5. **Association between functional consequences and variant categories and locations**: The paper also studied the relationship between functional consequences and variant categories and locations. Through Fisher's exact test and multiple comparison correction (False Discovery Rate, FDR 10%), the associations between functional changes within specific segments and domains and variants were determined.

6. **Population - level analysis**: The authors conducted a population - level analysis of the functional research variants of the SCN2A gene, evaluated the functional data coverage of the known disease - causing variants, in order to estimate the proportion of available functional information.

In summary, the main objective of this paper is to improve the clinical interpretation ability of ion channel variants related to epilepsy through the standardized and systematic evaluation of electrophysiological data, thereby improving diagnosis and treatment decisions.