Abstract:Learning to optimally predict rewards requires agents to account for fluctuations in reward value. Recent work suggests that individuals can efficiently learn about variable rewards through adaptation of the learning rate, and coding of prediction errors relative to reward variability. Such adaptive coding has been linked to midbrain dopamine neurons in nonhuman primates, and evidence in support for a similar role of the dopaminergic system in humans is emerging from fMRI data. Here, we sought to investigate the effect of dopaminergic perturbations on adaptive prediction error coding in humans, using a between-subject, placebo-controlled pharmacological fMRI study with a dopaminergic agonist (bromocriptine) and antagonist (sulpiride). Participants performed a previously validated task in which they predicted the magnitude of upcoming rewards drawn from distributions with varying SDs. After each prediction, participants received a reward, yielding trial-by-trial prediction errors. Under placebo, we replicated previous observations of adaptive coding in the midbrain and ventral striatum. Treatment with sulpiride attenuated adaptive coding in both midbrain and ventral striatum, and was associated with a decrease in performance, whereas bromocriptine did not have a significant impact. Although we observed no differential effect of SD on performance between the groups, computational modeling suggested decreased behavioral adaptation in the sulpiride group. These results suggest that normal dopaminergic function is critical for adaptive prediction error coding, a key property of the brain thought to facilitate efficient learning in variable environments. Crucially, these results also offer potential insights for understanding the impact of disrupted dopamine function in mental illness.SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT To choose optimally, we have to learn what to expect. Humans dampen learning when there is a great deal of variability in reward outcome, and two brain regions that are modulated by the brain chemical dopamine are sensitive to reward variability. Here, we aimed to directly relate dopamine to learning about variable rewards, and the neural encoding of associated teaching signals. We perturbed dopamine in healthy individuals using dopaminergic medication and asked them to predict variable rewards while we made brain scans. Dopamine perturbations impaired learning and the neural encoding of reward variability, thus establishing a direct link between dopamine and adaptation to reward variability. These results aid our understanding of clinical conditions associated with dopaminergic dysfunction, such as psychosis.

A mismatch between striatal cholinergic pauses and dopaminergic reward prediction errors

Subsecond dopamine fluctuations in human striatum encode superposed error signals about actual and counterfactual reward

Intrinsic dopamine and acetylcholine dynamics in the striatum of mice

Dopamine D2 Receptors Modulate the Cholinergic Pause and Inhibitory Learning

Intrinsic Reward-Like Dopamine and Acetylcholine Dynamics in Striatum

Acetylcholine demixes heterogeneous dopamine signals for learning and moving

Brief optogenetic inhibition of dopamine neurons mimics endogenous negative reward prediction errors

Dopamine–endocannabinoid Interactions Mediate Spike-Timing-dependent Potentiation in the Striatum

Dopamine Release Plateau and Outcome Signals in Dorsal Striatum Contrast with Classic Reinforcement Learning Formulations

Striatal cholinergic interneuron pause response requires Kv1 channels, is absent in dyskinetic mice, and is restored by dopamine D5 receptor inverse agonism

Subsecond fluctuations in extracellular dopamine encode reward and punishment prediction errors in humans

A causal link between prediction errors, dopamine neurons and learning

Dopamine neurons drive spatiotemporally heterogeneous striatal dopamine signals during learning

Dopamine dynamics are dispensable for movement but promote reward responses

Habenula Lesions Reveal that Multiple Mechanisms Underlie Dopamine Prediction Errors

Human dorsal striatal activity during choice discriminates reinforcement learning behavior from the gambler's fallacy

A novel critic signal in identified midbrain dopaminergic neurons of mice training in operant tasks

Dopamine release in human associative striatum during reversal learning

Dopamine Modulates Adaptive Prediction Error Coding in the Human Midbrain and Striatum

Nigrostriatal Dopamine Signals Sequence-Specific Action-Outcome Prediction Errors

Slowly Evolving Dopaminergic Activity Modulates the Moment-to-moment Probability of Reward-Related Self-Timed Movements