serial crystallography facilitates 96-well plate structural analysis at low symmetry

Nicolas Foos,Jean-Baptiste Florial,Mathias Eymery,Jeremy Sinoir,Franck Felisaz,Marcus Oscarsson,Antonia Beteva,Matthew W. Bowler,Didier Nurizzo,Gergely Papp,Montserrat Soler-Lopez,Max Nanao,Shibom Basu,Andrew A. McCarthy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.04.28.591338

2024-04-29

Abstract:The advent of serial crystallography has rejuvenated and popularised room temperature X-ray crystal structure determination. Structures determined at physiological temperature reveal protein flexibility and dynamics. In addition, challenging samples (e.g., large complexes, membrane proteins, and viruses) forming fragile crystals, are often difficult to harvest for cryo-crystallography. Moreover, a typical serial crystallography experiment requires a large number of microcrystals, mainly achievable through batch crystallisation. Many medically relevant samples are expressed in mammalian cell-lines, producing a meagre quantity of protein that is incompatible for batch crystallisation. This can limit the scope of serial crystallography approaches. Direct data collection from a 96-well crystallisation plate enables not only the identification of the best diffracting crystallisation condition, but also the possibility for structure determination at ambient conditions. Here, we describe an serial crystallography (iSX) approach, facilitating direct measurement from crystallisation plates, mounted on a rapidly exchangeable universal plate holder deployed at a microfocus beamline, ID23-2, at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF). We applied our iSX approach on a challenging project, Autotaxin, a therapeutic target expressed in a stable human cell-line, to determine a structure in the lowest symmetry 1 space group at 3.0 Å resolution. Our data collection strategy provided a complete dataset for structure determination, while screening various crystallisation conditions. Our data analysis reveals that the iSX approach is highly efficient at a microfocus beamline, improving throughput and demonstrating how crystallisation plates can be routinely used as an alternative method of presenting samples for serial crystallography experiments at synchrotrons.

Biophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to directly obtain high - quality protein structure data from 96 - well crystallization plates through the in situ serial crystallography (iSX) method, especially the structure analysis in the low - symmetry space group P1. Specifically, the authors successfully analyzed the structure of Autotaxin at a resolution of 3.0 Å at room temperature using the iSX method for a challenging project. This method not only improves the efficiency of data collection but also better preserves the physiological conformation of proteins, thus providing a more effective approach for structure - based drug discovery.

### Main problems:
1. **Improve data collection efficiency**: Traditional in - situ data collection methods are time - consuming and lack high - throughput and efficiency, which limits their application in routine experiments. The iSX method significantly shortens the data collection time through rapid switching and automated processes, making data collection on the micro - focused beamline more efficient.
2. **Preserve the physiological conformation of proteins**: Although traditional cryo - MX can analyze structures at near - atomic resolution, it cannot reveal the flexibility and dynamic changes of proteins under physiological conditions. The iSX method collects data at room temperature and can better preserve the physiological conformation of proteins, which is helpful for studying time - dependent structural changes and enzymatic catalysis processes.
3. **Suitable for samples with low expression levels**: Many medically - relevant samples have low expression levels in mammalian cell lines and it is difficult to obtain enough crystals by batch crystallization methods. The iSX method can directly collect data from 96 - well crystallization plates, is suitable for samples with low expression levels, and broadens the application range of serial crystallography.

### Solutions:
- **In - situ serial crystallography (iSX)**: By installing a dedicated plate manipulator (PM) on the micro - focused beamline ID23 - 2, rapid and efficient data collection from 96 - well crystallization plates is achieved.
- **Automated workflow**: Using MXCuBE - Web software, users can easily import visual scores, navigate to the droplets of interest, and automatically collect diffraction data.
- **Optimized data processing**: Through software tools such as crystFEL, a large number of static diffraction frames are indexed, merged, and processed, and finally high - quality structure data are obtained.

### Results:
- **Successful analysis of the autotaxin structure**: The structure of autotaxin was analyzed at a resolution of 3.0 Å, verifying the effectiveness of the iSX method.
- **Improved data collection efficiency**: Using the iSX method, a complete data set can be obtained from 10 droplets in only 1.5 hours, significantly improving the efficiency of data collection.
- **Preservation of physiological conformation**: Compared with cryo - SSX, the data collected by the iSX method at room temperature better preserves the physiological conformation of proteins, which is helpful for understanding the dynamics and functions of proteins.

In conclusion, this paper overcomes the limitations of traditional crystallography methods in terms of data collection efficiency, preservation of physiological conformation, and processing of samples with low expression levels by developing and applying the iSX method, providing a new and effective means for protein structure analysis.