Personality traits vary in their association with brain activity across situations

Samyogita Hardikar,Brontë McKeown,Adam Turnbull,Ting Xu,Sofie L. Valk,Boris C. Bernhardt,Daniel S. Margulies,Michael P. Milham,Elizabeth Jefferies,Robert Leech,Arno Villringer,Jonathan Smallwood

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.04.18.590056

2024-04-22

Abstract:Human cognition supports complex behaviour across a range of situations, and traits (such as personality) influence how we react in these different contexts. Although viewing traits as situationally grounded is common in social sciences it is often overlooked in neuroscience. Often studies focus on linking brain activity to trait descriptions of humans examine brain-trait associations in a single task, or, under passive conditions like wakeful rest. These studies, often referred to as brain wide association studies (BWAS) have recently become the subject of controversy because results are often unreliable even with large sample sizes. Although there are important statistical reasons why BWAS yield inconsistent results, we hypothesised that results are inconsistent because the situation in which brain activity is measured will impact the power in detecting a reliable link to a specific trait. To examine this possibility, we performed a state-space analysis in which tasks from the Human Connectome Project (HCP) were organized into a low-dimensional space based on how they activated different large-scale neural systems. We examined how individuals’ observed brain activity across these different contexts related to their personality. Our analysis found that for multiple personality traits (including Agreeableness, Openness to Experience and Conscientiousness) stronger associations with brain activity emerge in some tasks than others. These data establish that for specific personality traits there are situations in which reliable associations with brain activity can be identified with greater accuracy, highlighting the importance of context-bound views of understanding how brain activity links to trait variation in human behaviour.

Neuroscience

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: Are there differences in the association between personality traits and brain activity in different contexts? Specifically, the researchers are interested in whether the relationship between different personality traits (such as agreeableness, openness, conscientiousness, etc.) and brain activity varies across different task contexts. Traditional brain-wide association studies (BWAS) typically measure brain activity in only one specific context, which may lead to inconsistent and unreliable results. Therefore, this paper aims to verify whether the association between personality traits and brain activity is context-dependent by analyzing brain activity under different task contexts.

The researchers used data from the Human Connectome Project (HCP) to construct a state space that maps brain activity under different task conditions onto three major brain functional dimensions. Through this method, they found that certain personality traits have a more significant association with brain activity under certain task conditions, thus supporting the view that the association between personality traits and brain activity is context-dependent. This finding is important for understanding how personality traits influence brain activity and for designing more effective neuroscience research.