A natural ANI gap that can define intra-species units of bacteriophages and other viruses

Borja Aldeguer-Riquelme,Roth E Conrad,Josefa Antón,Ramon Rossello-Mora,Konstantinos T. Konstantinidis
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.04.18.590031
2024-04-18
Abstract:Despite the importance of intra-species variants of viruses for causing disease and/or disrupting ecosystem functioning, there is no universally applicable standard to define these. A 95% whole-genome average nucleotide identity (ANI) gap is commonly used to define species, especially for bacteriophages, but whether a similar gap exists within species that can be used to define intra-species units has not been evaluated yet. Whole-genome comparisons among members of 1,016 bacteriophage species revealed a region of low frequency of pairs around 99.2-99.8% ANI, showing 3-fold or fewer pairs than expected for an even or normal distribution. This second gap is prevalent in viruses infecting various cultured or uncultured hosts, and from a variety of environments, although a few exceptions to this pattern were also observed (∼3.7% of the total species evaluated) and are likely attributed to cultivation biases. Similar results were observed for a limited set of eukaryotic viruses that are adequately sampled including SARS-CoV-2, whose ANI-based clusters matched well the WHO-defined Variants of Concern, indicating that they represent functionally and/or ecologically distinct units. The existence of sequence-discrete units appears to be predominantly driven by (high) ecological cohesiveness coupled to either recombination frequency for bacteriophages or selection and clonal evolution for other viruses such as SARS-CoV-2. These results indicate that fundamentally different underlying mechanisms could lead to similar diversity patterns. Based on these results, we propose the 99.5% ANI as a practical, standardized, and data-supported threshold for defining viral intra-species units of bacteriophages, for which we propose the term genomovars.
Microbiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?