A shift from pleiotropic to modular adaptation revealed by a high-resolution two-step adaptive walk

Grant Kinsler,Yuping Li,Gavin Sherlock,Dmitri A. Petrov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.04.17.589938

2024-04-18

Abstract:Evolution by natural selection is expected to be a slow and gradual process. In particular, the mutations that drive evolution are predicted to be small and modular, incrementally improving a small number of traits. However, adaptive mutations identified early in microbial evolution experiments, cancer, and other systems often provide substantial fitness gains and pleiotropically improve multiple traits at once. We asked whether such pleiotropically adaptive mutations are common throughout adaptation or are instead a rare feature of early steps in evolution that tend to target key signaling pathways. To do so, we conducted barcoded second-step evolution experiments initiated from five first-step mutations identified from a prior yeast evolution experiment. We then isolated hundreds of second-step mutations from these evolution experiments, measured their fitness and performance in several growth phases, and conducted whole-genome sequencing of the second-step clones. Here, we found that while the vast majority of mutants isolated from the first-step of evolution in this condition show patterns of pleiotropic adaptation - improving both performance in fermentation and respiration growth phases - second-step mutations show a shift towards modular adaptation, mostly improving respiration performance and only rarely improving fermentation performance. We also identified a shift in the molecular basis of adaptation from genes in cellular signaling pathways towards genes involved in respiration and mitochondrial function. Our results suggest that the genes in cellular signaling pathways are particularly capable of providing large, adaptively pleiotropic benefits to the organism due to their ability to coherently affect many phenotypes at once. As such, these genes may serve as the source of pleiotropic adaptation in the early stages of evolution, and once these become exhausted, organisms then adapt more gradually, acquiring smaller, more modular mutations.

Evolutionary Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses the patterns of adaptive mutations in biological evolution, particularly the transition from pleiotropic adaptation to modular adaptation. The researchers observed the mutation effects in yeast when adapting to environmental changes through a high-resolution two-step adaptive walk experiment. They found that in the first stage of evolution, most mutations exhibited pleiotropic adaptation, which means that a mutation improved multiple traits simultaneously, such as performance in fermentation and respiratory growth phases. However, in the second stage, mutations tended to exhibit modular adaptation, primarily improving a single trait, such as respiratory performance, with fewer improvements in fermentation performance.

The study also found that early adaptive mutations were often associated with cellular signaling pathways, which can coordinately affect multiple phenotypes. As these crucial pathways become depleted through mutations, subsequent evolution relies on smaller and more specialized mutations. This suggests that cellular signaling pathways may provide abundant and adaptive pleiotropic benefits in early evolution, while later evolution becomes more gradual and accumulates smaller and more specific mutations.

In conclusion, the paper suggests that although adaptive mutations are theoretically expected to be small and modular, pleiotropic adaptation is common in practical microbial evolution experiments, especially in the early stages. As the evolution progresses, this pattern transitions to modular adaptation, which is consistent with theoretical predictions that long-term adaptive evolution occurs through smaller and incremental mutations.