IncC plasmid genome rearrangements influence the vertical and horizontal transmission tradeoff in Escherichia coli

Margaux Allain,Thibaut Morel-Journel,Benedicte Condamine,Benoist Gibeaux,Benoit Gachet,Remi GSCHWIND,Erick Denamur,Luce Landraud
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.04.17.589899
2024-07-24
Abstract:It has been shown that an evolutionary tradeoff between vertical (host growth rate) and horizontal (plasmid conjugation) transmissions contribute to global plasmid fitness. As conjugative IncC plasmids are important for the spread of multidrug resistance (MDR), in a broad range of bacterial hosts, we investigated vertical and horizontal transmissions of two multidrug-resistant IncC plasmids according to their backbones and MDR-region rearrangements, upon plasmid entry into a new host. We observed plasmid genome deletions after conjugation in three diverse natural Escherichia coli clinical strains, varying from null to high number depending on the plasmid, all occurring in the MDR-region. The plasmid burden on bacterial fitness depended more on the strain background than on the structure of the MDR-region, deletions appearing to have no impact. Besides, we observed an increase in plasmid transfer rate, from ancestral host to new clinical recipient strains, when the IncC plasmid was rearranged. Finally, using a second set of conjugation experiments, we investigated the evolutionary tradeoff of the IncC plasmid during the critical period of plasmid establishment in E. coli K-12, by correlating the transfer rates of deleted or non-deleted IncC plasmids and their costs on the recipient strain. Plasmid deletions strongly improved conjugation efficiency with no negative growth effect. Our findings indicate that the flexibility of the MDR-region of the IncC plasmids can promote their dissemination, and provide diverse opportunities to capture new resistance genes. In a broader view, they suggest that the vertical-horizontal transmission tradeoff can be manipulated by the plasmid to improve its fitness.
Microbiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore how IncC plasmid genome rearrangements affect the trade - off between its vertical (host growth rate) and horizontal (plasmid conjugation transfer) transmissions in Escherichia coli. Specifically, the study focused on the effects of the backbone and multi - drug - resistant region rearrangements of two multi - drug - resistant IncC plasmids on vertical and horizontal transmissions after they entered new hosts. The study experimentally observed the deletion of plasmid genomes after conjugation, evaluated the impact of plasmid carriage on bacterial fitness, and analyzed the transfer rates and stabilities of plasmids with different structures in different host backgrounds. Ultimately, the study explored how these rearrangements improve the overall fitness of plasmids by changing the trade - off between vertical and horizontal transmissions. ### Main research questions: 1. **Effects of IncC plasmid genome rearrangements on vertical and horizontal transmissions**: - The genome rearrangement situations of two multi - drug - resistant IncC plasmids after entering new clinical Escherichia coli strains were studied. - The effects of these rearrangements on plasmid vertical transmission (host growth rate) and horizontal transmission (plasmid conjugation transfer) were analyzed. 2. **Effects of plasmid carriage on bacterial fitness**: - The maximum growth rate (MGR) of transductants carrying plasmids with different structures was measured to evaluate the effects of plasmid carriage on bacterial fitness. - The growth burdens of clinical Escherichia coli strains with different backgrounds after carrying plasmids with different structures were compared. 3. **Effects of plasmid rearrangement on the efficiency of horizontal transmission**: - Through conjugation experiments, the transfer rates of donor strains carrying plasmids with different structures to receptor strains were compared. - Whether plasmid rearrangement improves the efficiency of plasmid horizontal transmission was analyzed. 4. **Effects of plasmid rearrangement on plasmid stability**: - Through in vitro evolution experiments, the effects of plasmid rearrangement on the stable maintenance of plasmids in new hosts were evaluated. - The evolution trajectories of plasmids in receptor strains with different backgrounds in the presence or absence of antibiotic selection pressure were observed. 5. **Effects of plasmid rearrangement on the trade - off between vertical and horizontal transmissions**: - Using E. coli K - 12 as a unified receptor strain to exclude the interference of host background, the effects of plasmid rearrangement on the trade - off between vertical and horizontal transmissions were further studied. - The contributions of plasmid rearrangement to the overall fitness of plasmids were analyzed by linear models. ### Conclusion: The study found that the multi - drug - resistant region of IncC plasmids is highly flexible, and this flexibility can promote plasmid transmission through genome rearrangement. Rearrangement not only improves the efficiency of plasmid horizontal transmission, but also has no negative impact on bacterial growth in some cases. These results indicate that plasmids can improve their fitness by regulating the trade - off between vertical and horizontal transmissions, thereby spreading more effectively in different hosts.