Implementing an Advance Choice Documents resource for Black African and Caribbean people with experience of compulsory psychiatric admission

Jonathan Simpson,Abigail Babatunde,Alan Simpson,Steven Gilbert,Alex Ruck Keene,Lucy Stephenson,Kia-Chong Chua,Gareth Owen,Fiona Crowe,Pauline Edwards,Selena Galloway,Megan Fisher,Marcela Schilderman,Anita Bignell,Shubulade Smith,Claire Henderson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.04.17.24305837

2024-10-30

Abstract:Background: Advance Choice Documents (ACDs) have been recommended for use in England and Wales based on evidence from trials that show that they can reduce involuntary hospitalisation, which disproportionately affects Black African and Caribbean people. Our aim was therefore to develop and implement an ACD resource for Black people who have previously been involuntarily hospitalised and the people that support them. Methods: Resource co-production workshops were held to inform the development of the ACD template and two types of training for all stakeholders, comprising a Recovery College course and simulation training. An ACD facilitator developed ACDs with service users and mental health staff over a series of meetings. Interviews with service user and staff participants were conducted after ACD completion and analysed to document their experience of the process and opinions on ACDs. Other implementation strategies were also employed alongside to support and optimise the development of ACDs. Results: Nine ACDs were completed and were largely reported as appropriate, acceptable, and feasible to staff and service users. Both reported it being an empowering process that encouraged hope for better future treatment and therefore better wellbeing. Uncertainty was also expressed about the confidence people had that ACDs would be adhered to/honoured, primarily due to staff workload. The information provision training and the skills training were generally considered to be informative by attendees. Conclusions: The project has developed an ACD development resource that was reported as agreeable to all stakeholders; however, the generalisability of the findings is limited due to the small sample size. The project also highlights the importance of staff and ACD facilitator capacity and good therapeutic relationships in ACD completion. Further research is needed to determine the adjustments needed for large scale use, including for those under age 18 and those under the care of forensic mental health services; and how to include carers/supporters more in the process.