A Critical Analysis of UK Media Characterisations of Long Covid in Children and Young People

Chloe Connor,Michael Kranert,Sara Mckelvie,Donna Clutterbuck,Sammie Mcfarland,Nisreen A Alwan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.04.13.24305152

2024-04-15

Abstract:Long Covid is the continuation or development of symptoms related to a SARSCoV2 infection. Those with Long Covid may face epistemic injustice, where they are unjustifiably viewed as unreliable evaluators of their own illness experiences. Media articles both reflect and influence perception and subsequently how people regard children and young people (CYP) with Long Covid, and may contribute to epistemic injustice. We aimed to explore how the UK media characterises Long Covid in CYP through examining three key actor groups: parents, healthcare professionals, and CYP with Long Covid, through the lens of epistemic injustice. A systematic search strategy resulted in the inclusion of 103 UK media articles. We used an adapted corpus-assisted Critical Discourse Analysis in tandem with thematic analysis. Specifically, we utilised search terms to locate concordances of key actor groups. In the corpus, parents highlighted minimisation of Long Covid, barriers to care, and experiences of personal attacks. Mothers were presented as also having Long Covid. Fathers were not mentioned once. Healthcare professionals emphasised the rarity of Long Covid in CYP, avoided pathologizing Long Covid, and overemphasised psychological components. CYP rarely were consulted in media articles but were presented as formerly very able. Manifestations of Long Covid in CYP were validated or invalidated in relation to adults. Media characterisations contributed to epistemic injustice. The disempowering portrayal of parents promote stigma and barriers to care. Healthcare professionals’ narratives often contributed to negative healthcare experiences and enacted testimonial injustice, where CYP and parent’s credibility was diminished due to unfair identity prejudice, in their invalidation of Long Covid. Media characterisations reveal and maintain a lack of societal framework for understanding Long Covid in CYP. The findings of this study illustrate the discursive practices employed by journalists that contribute to experiences of epistemic injustice. Based on our findings, we propose recommendations for journalists.

Public and Global Health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper mainly discusses the portrayal of long Covid symptoms in children and adolescents by the British media. The study points out that long Covid patients may face cognitive injustice, meaning that their illness experiences are unreasonably perceived as unreliable. Media articles both reflect and influence the public's perception of children and adolescents with long Covid, which can lead to cognitive injustice. The study analyzed 103 British media articles through a systematic search strategy and employed an adaptive corpus-assisted critical discourse analysis and thematic analysis.

In media coverage, parents emphasize their experiences of long Covid being underestimated, barriers to medical treatment, and personal attacks. Mothers are usually depicted as also suffering from long Covid, while fathers are not mentioned. Healthcare professionals emphasize the rarity of this condition in children and adolescents, avoid pathologizing it, and overemphasize psychological factors. Children and adolescent patients themselves are rarely directly consulted in media reports but are portrayed as previously very healthy. The media's portrayal of long Covid symptoms in children is either confirmed or denied and often compared with symptoms in adults.

The media's portrayal exacerbates cognitive injustice, depicting parents as incompetent and increasing stigma and barriers to medical treatment. The discourse of healthcare professionals often leads to negative medical experiences, implementing testimonial injustice, which weakens the credibility of patients and parents due to unfair identity biases. The study reveals a lack of societal understanding of long Covid in children, and the media's descriptions uphold this status quo. Based on these findings, the paper provides recommendations to journalists.

The research methodology includes collecting media articles on long Covid in children from national newspapers in the UK from January 1, 2020, to June 7, 2023. It involves systematic search and screening, utilizing critical discourse analysis based on the key actors theory to analyze the roles and narratives of parents, healthcare professionals, and affected children in the media.